6/25/2020 Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court extremely difficult to answer the requirement of equality in the value of votes, while maintaining the mechanism designed to use a prefecture as a unit of constituency. The judgment then stated that the disparity in the value of votes in the election held without changing the mechanism was in an unconstitutional state, and that legislative measures to reform the current system of setting the number of seats for each prefecture-based constituency should be taken. The 2014 Grand Bench Judgment held that the provisions of the apportionment of seats by the 2012 Revision Act, which was enacted after the 2012 Grand Bench Judgment and under which the 2013 Election was held, maintained the mechanism of the system, and therefore was insufficient to correct the unconstitutional state. In light of the above, in determining whether or not the disparity in the value of votes in the Election has been removed from its unconstitutional state by the Provisions of the Apportionment of Seats, it is important to consider whether or not the legislative measures to reform the current system were taken, as referred in the 2012 Grand Bench Judgment. The Provisions of the Apportionment of Seats by the 2015 Revision Act reformed the previous system of using a prefecture as a unit for all constituencies, by merging constituencies. In substance, this reform only transformed four constituencies consisting of four prefectures into two constituencies consisting of four prefectures by conducting two mergers of constituencies, which combine two prefectures into one constituency, and maintains the system of using a prefecture as a unit of constituency. As it is shown by the facts that, based on the population counted by the population census conducted in 2010, which was referred to at the time of prescribing the Provisions of the Apportionment of Seats, the maximum disparity was 1:2.97, and became 1:3.08 at the time of the Election, it is hard to say that the Provisions of the Apportionment of Seats are “reasonable” legislative measures to deal with the disparity in the value of votes in response to population migration. The disparity in the value of votes shown by the maximum disparity of 1:3.08 at the time of the Election has surely become lower compared to the maximum disparities at the time of previous elections. However, this result is derived from the provisions of the apportionment of seats that maintain the system of using a prefecture as a basic unit of constituency, and there is a fear that the disparity will expand further if no other measures are taken. The supplementary provision of the 2015 Revision Act states that, taking into consideration correction of the disparity, etc., review will be made continuously, definitely working toward a conclusion on the fundamental reform of the election system. This fact indicates that the 2015 Revision Act itself needs further review and is insufficient to correct the unconstitutional state. Therefore, it should be held that the disparity in the value of votes in the Election was not removed from its unconstitutional state even after the 2015 Revision. 5. Whether or not the failure is within the bounds of the Diet's discretion Previous judgments of the Grand Bench pointed out that the provisions of the apportionment of seats before the 2015 Revision had used a prefecture as a unit for all of the constituencies and saw it as a problem that this point had not been corrected in any way through legal revisions even after this court pointed it out as the cause of the unconstitutional state. In connection with this, with regard to the criterion for determination of [ii], whether the failure is within the bounds of the Diet's discretion, as stated in Section 3 above, the judgments of the Grand Bench focused on whether or not the period after a judgment of this court is rendered and until an https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534 13/24

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents