11
the FEC’s regulation of non-profit entities that are not
connected to a candidate, party, or for-profit corporation. We
thus must consider how the constitutional principles outlined
above apply to non-profits – and in particular to three
different kinds of non-profits: (i) those that only make
expenditures; (ii) those that only make contributions to
candidates or parties; and (iii) those that do both. For
purposes of the First Amendment analysis, the central issue
turns out to be whether independent non-profits are treated
like individual citizens (who under Buckley have the right to
spend unlimited money to support their preferred candidates)
or like political parties (which under McConnell do not have
the right to raise and spend unlimited soft money).7
1
The first relevant category of non-profit entities consists
of those that only make expenditures for political activities
such as advertisements, get-out-the-vote efforts, and voter
7
In referring to non-profit entities, we mean non-connected
non-profit corporations (usually advocacy or ideological or
politically oriented non-profits) that engage in election-related
activities and register with the Internal Revenue Service under 26
U.S.C. § 527 or § 501(c), as well as unincorporated non-profit
groups. “Non-connected” means that the non-profit is not a
candidate committee, a party committee, or a committee established
by a corporation or labor union. See 11 C.F.R. § 106.6(a). “Nonconnected” for purposes of this opinion also excludes so-called
leadership PACs.
Some non-profits register with the FEC as political
committees; others do not. Our constitutional analysis of donations
to and spending by non-connected non-profits applies regardless
whether a non-profit has registered as a political committee with the
FEC. See infra note 15.