STRØBYE AND ROSENLIND v. DENMARK JUDGMENT
“... iii. to ensure that no person with a disability is excluded from the right to vote or
to stand for election on the basis of her/his disability; ...”
70. In its report of 30 October 2014 on Denmark, the United Nations
Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities expressed, inter alia,
the following concern under the heading “Participation in political and
public life” (“Article 29):
“The Committee is concerned that under the Constitution, the Parliamentary
Elections Act and other electoral laws, and the Guardianship Act (section 6), persons
under guardianship are not allowed to vote or to stand for election in parliamentary,
municipal, regional or European Parliament elections, or referendums. The Committee
is also concerned that election materials are reportedly rarely accessible to blind
persons or to persons with learning and intellectual disabilities, that polling stations
are often not physically accessible, that ballots may not be accessible to blind persons,
and that persons under guardianship may not be able to freely choose the kind of
voting assistance that they would wish to use.
The Committee recommends that the State party amend the relevant laws, including
the Parliamentary Elections Act and other laws governing municipal, regional and
European Parliament elections, so that all persons with disabilities can enjoy the right
to vote and stand for election regardless of guardianship or other regimes. It also
recommends that the State party ensure, through legislative and other measures, the
accessibility of ballots and election materials, and of polling stations, and that it
ensure that freely chosen, adequate and necessary assistance is provided in order to
facilitate voting by all persons.”
71. A report by the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights of
21 May 2014 on “The right to political participation for persons with
disabilities: human rights indicators” stated among other things (pages
40-41):
“Seven out of the 28 EU Member States – Austria, Croatia, Italy, Latvia, the
Netherlands, Sweden and the United Kingdom – guarantee the right to vote for all
persons with disabilities, including those without legal capacity.
In Croatia, legal reform in December 2012 abolished the exclusion of persons
without legal capacity from the right to vote, meaning that people deprived of legal
capacity were able to participate in the European Parliament and local elections in
2013. Similarly, amendments to the Latvian Civil Code which came into force in 2013
end the denial of the right to vote for those deprived of legal capacity. The relevant
electoral legislation has not yet been amended, however, meaning people deprived of
legal capacity can be barred from voting.
A second group of EU Member States have a system whereby an assessment is
made of the individual’s actual ability to vote. In Hungary, a system where everyone
under guardianship was prohibited from voting was changed in 2012; now judges
decide whether persons with “limited mental capacities” are allowed to vote. In
Slovenia, the legal test for judges deciding whether to restrict the right to vote is
whether the person with a disability is capable of understanding the meaning, purpose
and effect of elections.
A further 15 EU Member States prohibit people with disabilities who have been
deprived of their legal capacity from voting. The Member States are Belgium,
Bulgaria, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Lithuania,
22