24
MCCUTCHEON v. FEDERAL ELECTION COMM’N
Opinion of ROBERTS, C. J.
diminished, and with it the potential for corruption.
It is not clear how many candidates a PAC must support
before our dedicated donor can avoid being tagged with
the impermissible knowledge that “a substantial portion”
of his contribution will go to Smith. But imagine that the
donor is one of ten equal donors to a PAC that gives the
highest possible contribution to Smith.8 The PAC may
give no more than $2,600 per election to Smith. Of that
sum, just $260 will be attributable to the donor intent on
circumventing the base limits. Thus far he has hardly
succeeded in funneling “massive amounts of money” to
Smith. Buckley, supra, at 38.
But what if this donor does the same thing via, say, 100
different PACs? His $260 contribution will balloon to
$26,000, ten times what he may contribute directly to
Smith in any given election.
This 100-PAC scenario is highly implausible. In the
first instance, it is not true that the individual donor will
necessarily have access to a sufficient number of PACs to
effectuate such a scheme. There are many PACs, but they
are not limitless. For the 2012 election cycle, the FEC
reported about 2,700 nonconnected PACs (excluding PACs
that finance independent expenditures only). And not
every PAC that supports Smith will work in this scheme:
For our donor’s pro rata share of a PAC’s contribution to
Smith to remain meaningful, the PAC must be funded by
only a small handful of donors. The antiproliferation
rules, which were not in effect when Buckley was decided,
prohibit our donor from creating 100 pro-Smith PACs of
his own, or collaborating with the nine other donors to do
——————
8 Even those premises are generous because they assume that the
donor contributes to non-multicandidate PACs, which are relatively
rare. Multicandidate PACs, by contrast, must have more than 50
contributors. 11 CFR §100.5(e)(3). The more contributors, of course,
the more the donor’s share in any eventual contribution to Smith is
diluted.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents