Page: 72
is impractical to call hundreds of witnesses: Philip Morris Products SA v Marlboro Canada Ltd,
[199] The respondent MPs contend that the EKOS Survey is inadmissible hearsay as it is
tendered for the purpose of establishing contested facts, namely the proof that actual voters were
prevented from voting. The applicants, they argue, do not merely use it as evidence that there
was a program of voter suppression, but as evidence that this program was effective and did
suppress voters.
[200] The applicants submit that in dealing with fraud preventing voting, there is no readily
available way to count the electors who did not vote other than through such a survey. They rely
on the statements by the Supreme Court in Opitz at paragraphs 23 and 72 that the assessment
under s 524 cannot involve an investigation into voters’ actual choices and that the evidence
must not compromise the secrecy of the ballot. The only reasonable alternative, they submit, was
for a qualified professional to conduct a survey.
[201] In my view, there was no question that the survey evidence was relevant. I concluded that
it was admissible in support of Mr. Graves’ opinion subject to the principles set out in Mattel,
above, that it was properly designed and conducted in an impartial manner. I found that the
survey was “both reliable (in the sense that if the survey were repeated it would likely produce
the same results) and valid (in the sense that the right questions have been put to the right pool of
respondents in the right way, in the right circumstances to provide the information sought)”:
Mattel, para 45. The weight to be given to it remained to be determined.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
2010 FC 1099 at para 259.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents