Page: 83
is, if targeted non-voters had actually voted, it appears more likely they would
have voted for the Conservative candidate.
One can go further than concluding that there is no material voter suppression
demonstrated for any of the Subject Ridings. A statistical analysis based on Mr.
Graves’s own data shows that there is less likelihood that alleged “voter
suppression” took place in the Subject Ridings altogether, compared to anywhere
else in Canada.
[229] I found Dr. Corbin’s evidence to be overly argumentative. In her critique of Mr. Graves’ use
of the IVR technology and his opinion evidence, she appeared to enter the arena as an advocate. I
agree with the respondent MPs that election annulment proceedings should not be a “battle of the
experts” but it seems to me that they encouraged Dr. Corbin to engage in just such a battle.
(7)
Dr. Nevitte’s evidence
[230] The applicants retained Dr. Neil Nevitte, an expert in survey research and electoral
behaviour, to assess the evidence of both Dr. Corbin and Mr. Graves. Dr. Nevitte is a professor
of political science at the University of Toronto and a researcher in the areas of public opinion,
voting, value change, and the problems associated with transitional elections. He was a coinvestigator of the Canadian Election Studies (1993-2009), serves as a Senior Election Advisor
with the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs and is a technical advisor to
international non-governmental organizations on the prevention and detection of election fraud
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents