Page: 89
B.
Did the fraud affect the results of the election in the six subject ridings?
direct evidence that the voter suppression efforts had been successful. They themselves had not
been prevented from voting by the misleading telephone calls that they received. As they point
out, however, to require direct evidence of the effects of voter suppression measures may make it
much more difficult to bring such challenges under s 524 of the Act. There is no readily available
means to count the number of electors who were not able to vote by virtue of the fraudulent
activity unless they all come forward and self-identify, which is highly improbable.
[248] The applicants reasonably turned to a random interactive telephone survey as an
alternative means to collect the data. They ask the Court to extrapolate, from the survey samples,
an estimate of the total number of persons who did not vote in the six ridings as a result of the
misleading calls and to draw the necessary inference as to the effect on the outcome in each
riding. It would be easier to draw those inferences if, as the respondent MPs argued, at least
some of the supporters of the losing candidates in the six ridings who did not vote because of the
misdirecting phone calls would have come forward to make that known at the time of the
election or when the story broke in the national media ten months later. That this did not occur
has raised questions that have not been answered in this proceeding.
[249] Apart from the survey, there is no evidence that the election results in the six ridings
would have turned out differently. This is not a case of disappearing ballots or tampering with
voting machines as in some of the American cases in which survey evidence has been accepted.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
[247] The applicants had a difficult obstacle to overcome in these proceedings. They had no
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents