have adopted rules of procedure exclusively
dedicated to election petition proceedings, clearly
marking a distinction between presidential and
other election petition proceedings.44 These
rules of procedure and substantive electoral laws
constitute complete codes for the determination
of election petitions in each country. Some go to
some degree of confusion in that procedural issues
are provided for in substantive legislation. This
has made election petition litigation a minefield for
blooming lawyers, who often are deceived by rules
of procedure, neglecting procedural issues, which
are contained in substantive law.45 In jurisdictions
where courts generally embrace technicalities, such
petitions are often dismissed before consideration
of substantive issues.
THIS HAS MADE ELECTION
PETITION LITIGATION A
MINEFIELD FOR BLOOMING
LAWYERS, WHO OFTEN ARE
DECEIVED BY RULES OF
PROCEDURE, NEGLECTING
PROCEDURAL ISSUES,
WHICH ARE CONTAINED IN
SUBSTANTIVE LAW
There seems to be consensus that the petitioner
has the obligation to prove allegations46 to the
required standard in that jurisdiction and establish
the grounds upon which they seek the court to
nullify an election. The grounds may be civil or
criminal in nature. The Seychelles Court of Appeal
summed up the transition of the “petitioner should
prove” principle from conventional civil litigation
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
into domain of election petition proceedings
and demonstrated its endorsement by other
jurisdictions across African countries. In the case
of Wavel John Charles Ramkalawan v Electoral
Commissioner and Others,47 it was held as follows:
In the case of Joseph Constantine Steamship
Line Limited v Imperial Smelting Corporation
(1942) AC 154, it was held that the burden of
proving their claim was upon the claimant, and
this burden, they had failed to discharge with the
result that the claim had to be dismissed. This
rule has continued to apply in election petitions.
Thus, in the case of Opitz vs Wrzesnewskyj (2012)
SCC 55-2012-10-56, it was held that an applicant
who seeks to annul an election bears the legal
proof throughout. In the Ugandan case of Col.
Dr. Kizza Besigye vs Museveni Yoweri Kaguta and
Electoral Commission (2001) UGSC, it was held
that the burden of proof in electoral petitions
as in other civil cases is settled, it lies on the
petitioner to prove his case to the satisfaction of
the court.48
In the case of Buhari and Ors v Obasanjo & Ors,
the Nigerian Supreme Court concluded that “the
onus has not by any means shifted from the timehonoured law on evidence that the person who
asserts a situation must prove.”49 The Constitutional
Court of Zimbabwe recently held that “the onus
and burden of proof … therefore rests with the
applicant and it is for him to prove…”50 Thus, in the
first instance, this burden falls on the petitioner.
This is based on the rationale that it is the petitioner
who seeks invalidation of the election. It appears
that the petitioner’s burden to prove their case
is implied in the legal provisions providing for
standard of proof. For instance, Section 59(6)
of the Ugandan Presidential Elections Act
provides that “the election of a candidate as
See illustratively, the Kenyan Elections (Parliamentary and County Elections) Petition Rules, 2013;
A case in point is that of the Zimbabwean Electoral Act, 2005, which contains a good deal of procedural issues even though there was also adopted the Electoral Court Rules of
Procedure (1995).
See Opitz v. Wrzesnewskyj 2012 SCC 55; Amama Mbabazi v. Yoweri Kaguta Museveni & 2 others Presidential Petition No. 01/2016; Abubakar v. Yar’adua [2009] ALL FWLR (PT.
457)1 SC.
Ramkalawan v Electoral Commissioner and Others Constitutional Appeal SCA CP 1/2016 (c).
As above, para 90.
Buhari v Obasanjo (2005) CLR 7K, p70.
Chamisa v Mnangagwa (CCZ 42/18) Judgment No. CCZ 21/19 (24 August 2018 – full Judgment), p2. For the Namibian position, see generally Itula & Ors v Minister of Urban and
Rural Development & Ors (A1-2019) [2020] NASC (5 February 2020).
91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents