President shall only be annulled ... if proved to
the satisfaction of the court.” This is a positive
obligation on the petitioner.51
BURDEN OF PROOF. DOES IT SHIFT?
The courts have also determined whether the
burden of proof shifts to the respondent at any
point of the election petition proceedings. In Buhari
v Obasanjo,52 the Nigerian Supreme Court held that
indeed the burden shifts and the circumstances under
which this happens. The Court stated as follows:
In general, in a civil case, the party that asserts in
its pleadings the existence of a particular fact is
required to prove such fact by adducing credible
evidence. If the party fails to do so, its case will
fail. On the other hand, if the party succeeds in
adducing evidence to prove the pleaded fact, it
is said to have discharged the burden of proof
that rests on it. The burden is then said to have
shifted to the party’s adversary to prove that the
fact established by the evidence adduced, could
not on the preponderance of the evidence, result
in the court giving judgment in favour of the party.53
In 2017, the Kenyan Supreme Court reaffirmed what
it referred to as “emerging jurisprudence” on the
burden and standard of proof in election petition
proceedings. In Odinga & Anor v Independent
Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Ors case
(2017 Odinga case),54 the Court ruled that the
petitioner’s burden “remains constant throughout a
trial.” Nonetheless, “depending on the effectiveness
with which he or she discharges this, the evidential
burden keeps shifting” and “its position at any
time is determined by answering the question as
to who would lose if no further evidence were
introduced.”55 Similarly, in the Chamisa case, the
Zimbabwean Constitutional Court did not shift
the burden to the EMB based on the finding
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
92
that the petitioner had not adduced evidence to
support allegations of irregularities.56 In particular,
the Court insisted on the document known as
the V11 Form, which was filled in with the total
votes each candidate got at each polling station.
The information was necessary for the Court to
appreciate the disparities alleged by the petitioner.
More recently, in the Chilima case, the Malawian
Constitutional Court held that “once a prima facie
case has been made out, the evidential burden
shifts to the respondent to disprove or rebut it.
However, the petitioner still bears the legal burden
of proof.”57 The Court reasoned that the justification
of the shift is rooted in the right of access to courts.
Without shifting the burden, “it would be a tall order
for the poor and uneducated citizens to prove their
rights and access justice in our courts.”58
Therefore, it appears Africa Sub-Sahara jurisdictions
follow the approach that once “credible, coherent,
and cogent” evidence on these two legs of proof59
has been set out (prima facie case), the burden
shifts to the respondent to show either that there
was no failure to comply with the law, or if there
was any non-compliance, it did not affect the
result of the election. This observation puts paid to
allegations that petition proceedings are sui generis
and fundamentally different from conventional
civil litigation. In fact, on several occasions, courts
across the sub-region have demonstrated the
indelible link between established common law
principles on civil litigation and modern election
petition proceedings. The latter’s feet are planted
in the former, from which it draws its origin.
Accordingly, treating election petition proceedings
as “in a class of their own” has no material application
to the burden of proof. It resides with the petitioner
and only shifts to the respondent or as between
the parties when the question is asked: which party
stands to lose if no further evidence is produced?
Mbowe v Elinfoo (1967) EA 240 Georges, CJ in the Tanzanian High Court held that ‘… in my view it is clear that the burden of proof must be on the Petitioner rather than the
Respondent, because it is he who seeks to have this election declared void’.
The Buhari Judgment (n 170).
As above 27.
Odinga & Anor v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Ors.
The Odinga Judgment (n 162) para 32.
The Chamisa Judgment (n 171) 84.
Chilima Judgment, para 1039.
Chilima Judgment, para 1040.
That is, non-compliance with laws or criminal offences and substantial effect on the result of the election.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents