respondent had committed to check his e-mail for
the pleadings. On appeal, the High Court held that
e-mail and WhatsApp are not recognized modes
of service under the law.53 In addition, the Court
asserted that there was no evidence to show that
the e-mail belonged to the respondent (at the
PPDT), and the cell phone number at the centre of
the WhatsApp service was not provided. It was the
Court’s view that there was no evidence to show
that the respondent had been served. In a different
case, the High Court held that WhatsApp is not
only not a recognized mode of service — it raises
questions of proof of delivery, acknowledgement
of receipt of service, and proof of identity of the
intended recipient.54 Even so, the High Court is on
record for accepting service through WhatsApp on
the basis of efficient use of available judicial and
administrative resources for expeditious resolution
of electoral disputes.55
EDR bodies cannot ignore the costliness of
advertisements in the daily newspapers, the strict
electoral timelines, and political nature of disputes
that make direct service impossible and even
risky. There is need for a legislative intervention
to allow service through WhatsApp, subject to
the communication of contents of pleadings and
satisfaction of attendant threshold.56
EDR BODIES CANNOT
IGNORE THE COSTLINESS
OF ADVERTISEMENTS IN
THE DAILY NEWSPAPERS,
THE STRICT ELECTORAL
TIMELINES, AND POLITICAL
NATURE OF DISPUTES
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
JURISDICTION
The PPDT’s jurisdiction has already been
highlighted above. For some of these disputes,
the PPDT can entertain them only after they have
been determined by a party’s internal dispute
resolution mechanism (IDRM). Nonetheless, the
PPDT has original jurisdiction with respect to
disputes arising out of party primaries; they must
have gone through an IDRM, as indicated under
the Political Parties Act.57 The specific mandate on
party primaries was introduced in the year 2016,
thus amending the substantive provision.58 The
memorandum of objects and reasons is silent on
whether it was the intention of the amending Bill
to exempt party primary disputes from IDRM, or
whether the omission was accidental.59 The PPDT
has taken inconsistent and unfortunate stances
towards this issue oscillating between IDRM having
original jurisdiction and the PPDT having both
original and appellate jurisdiction. It has held that
its jurisdiction on party primaries can be invoked
only when the IDRM process is over, although the
High Court overturned this decision on the grounds
that the statutory wording is clear, and there is no
requirement to exhaust the IDRM route first.60 The
High Court stated that the PPDT’s jurisdiction on
party primaries is as stated in law and cannot be
taken away from the PPDT, regardless of whether
there had been an IDRM process.61 The Court said
there may be value in demanding submission of
party disputes to IDRM, to promote alternative
dispute resolution, and to avoid the PPDT being
overburdened with such cases, yet the question
that arises is at whose cost? Moreover, it cannot
be valid to allege that Parliament forgot to subject
such disputes to IDRM; neither the courts nor
the PPDT are seers who can predict what the
Legislature ought to have included. In a slightly
different case, before introduction of the provision
on party primaries, the PPDT’s view was that it has
Shallo v Jubilee Party of Kenya & another [2017] eKLR. http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/137150/
Chama Cha Mashinani Elections Board & 2 Others v Beatrice Chebomui (2017) eKLR. http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/136311/
PPDT complaint No. 58 of 2017.
Political Parties Act 11 of 2011 sec 40(2).
Political Parties Amendment 2 Act of 2016.
As above.
PPDT Complaint 69 of 2017 Joseph Mboya Nyamuthe v Orange Democratic Movement & another, Election Petition Appeal 5 of 2017 Joseph Mboya Nyamuthe v Orange
Democratic Movement & 4 others [2017] eKLR.
Election Petition Appeal 5 of 2017 Nyamuthe v Orange Democratic Movement & 4 Ors [2017] eKLR. http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/139798/
PPDT Complaint No. 29 of 2015 Ibrahim Abdi Ali v Mohamed Abdi Farah & another.
PPDT No.387 of 2017 Ndegwa & Ors v Jubilee Party. http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/141669
Constitution of Kenya art 90 (2)(c).
County Governments Act, 2012 sec 7(2) (a).
31
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents