EMERGING ISSUES AND THEMES DURING THE IEBC
EDR PROCESS
VALIDITY OF THE MEMORANDUM
OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN IEBC
AND PPDT
The Political Parties Act establishes the PPDT with a
broad jurisdiction, including settlement of disputes
on party primaries and between members and their
political parties. The IEBC, as stated elsewhere,
has the power to settle all pre-election disputes,
including nomination disputes. Even though
nomination is defined in the Elections Act as the
submission to the IEBC of the name of a candidate
for election, the wording in Article 88(4) (e) of the
Constitution and Section 74(1) of the Elections
Act does not limit the IEBC from settling disputes
arising out of the political parties’ processes of
selecting candidates. The PPDT’s jurisdiction on
party primary disputes was introduced through the
Political Parties (Amendment) Bill of 2016 to address
the challenge of concurrent jurisdiction with other
bodies handling electoral disputes.76
Aware of the issue of forum shopping, IEBC and
PPDT signed a Memorandum of Understanding
(MoU) on 28 March 2017 to provide for the various
types of disputes that each institution is meant
to handle.77 The MoU requires IEBC to settle
disputes that relate to and directly affect the rights
and abilities of party members and citizens to
participate as candidates in the elections including:
a. Decisions of the returning officers regarding the
registration of candidates;
b. The Constitutional and statutory qualifications of
a member or a candidate nominated by a political
party or an independent candidate; and
c. The Constitutional and statutory qualifications of
women, youth, persons with disabilities, ethnic
minorities and the marginalized candidates under
Article 90 of the Constitution.
76
77
78
34
On the other hand, the PPDT is required to settle
disputes that relate to instances where party
members/citizens are denied/obstructed from
exercising their rights within the political party, such
as the preparations of party nomination lists for
candidates in the general elections.
It is not debatable that the exercise of
constitutionally accorded authority can only be
constitutional if exercised within the parameters
set and or contemplated in the Constitution. A
deviation is an affront to the rule of law, regardless
of whether or not the Constitutional Court has
addressed the action or omission. It is in the
interest of public bodies that exist on the strength
of social contract to align with constitutionality,
because they exercise their power on behalf of
the people. Contrary action entitles the people to
repudiate the contract. In addition, the ramifications
of unconstitutional actions, even when there is no
immediate adverse effect on the people, or even
when done under the guise of protecting the interests
of the people, are dire and certain. The history of
Kenya and the world at large has no shortage of
examples on the significance of the rule of law.
Having acknowledged the risk that faces the MoU,
it is necessary to assert that the MoU made it
possible for aggrieved persons to access justice. It
is also notable that the number of complaints filed
at the IEBC reduced drastically as compared to the
2013 general election experience, when IEBC heard
more than 2,000 cases.78
At <http://kenyalaw.org/kl/fileadmin/pdfdownloads/bills/2016/PoliticalParties_Amendment_Bill2016.pdf> (accessed 1 April 2020).
Political Parties Disputes Tribunal ´MoU between PPDT&IEBC on Dispute Resolution Signed on 28th March 2017´ available at <http://ppdt.judiciary.go.ke/political-party-resources/>
(accessed 1 April 2020).
At https://www.eisa.org/pdf/eh2014ken.pdf (accessed 2 March 2021).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents