JURISDICTION REGARDING
POLITICAL PARTIES’ PROCESSES
OF SELECTING CANDIDATES
As the substance of the MoU between IEBC and
PPDT indicates, there was no intention on the part
of IEBC to settle electoral disputes of this type.
Aggrieved persons nevertheless lodged complaints
with the DRC.
In the case of IEBC Dispute Resolution Committee
Complaint No. 315 of 2017, the DRC declined to
entertain the dispute, citing lack of jurisdiction,
based on the MoU and PPDT´s sole jurisdiction
on party primaries. The complainant had alleged
that he won the party primaries but his political
party, Orange Democratic Movement, awarded the
nomination certificate to his opponent.79 On appeal,
the Court of Appeal observed that the conferment
of jurisdiction on the PPDT to hear and determine
disputes relating to party primaries under the
Political Parties Act does not outweigh the IEBC’s
jurisdiction to adjudicate a dispute arising from
nominations provided such jurisdiction is properly
invoked.80 It also observed that the MoU cannot
take away jurisdiction from the IEBC. Consequently,
the court remitted the complaint back to the IEBC.
THE EFFECT OF SECTION 40
OF THE POLITICAL PARTIES ACT
The PPDT has both original and appellate
jurisdiction to hear and determine party primary
disputes. Party primary disputes can be lodged
directly at the PPDT or as an appeal from the party’s
Internal Disputes Resolution Mechanism (IDRM).
When one chooses to ignore the MoU, the PPDT
still has jurisdiction. Nonetheless, the Political
Parties Act cannot be employed by the IEBC to
abdicate its duty, especially given that it derives
its responsibility from the Constitution. Although
the problem of forum-shopping exists, it cannot be
solved by absconding duty and neglecting clear
provisions of the law. A recommendation has been
discussed below in this chapter.
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
JURISDICTION OF THE IEBC TO ENTERTAIN
DISPUTES ON INTEGRITY OF CANDIDATES
Every person has the duty to implement the
Leadership and Integrity Act, but the EACC has
the specific responsibility of implementation.
Regarding elections, the Act requires candidates
to bind themselves under oath through a statutory
declaration that they have the requisite integrity.81
During registration of candidates for elections, the
required documents for qualification include the
statutory declaration.82 It is instructive to use the
MoU to point out that the IEBC had indicated that it
would entertain disputes relating to qualifications of
candidates (at registration for elections). As a result
of these and its role to settle disputes, complaints
have been lodged to challenge the integrity of
candidates. The IEBC nonetheless dismissed the
disputes, on the grounds of lack of jurisdiction on
matters of integrity.83 It is worth mentioning that
where a person has been found in accordance
with any law to have contravened Chapter Six of
the Constitution, they can only be disqualified to
contest elections if all possibility of appeal or review
of the relevant decision has been exhausted.84
TIMELINES SET BY IEBC RELATING
TO CANDIDATE NOMINATION
The DRC heard and determined complaints related
to failure or inability of a candidate to present
themselves before the Returning Officers with all
required documents within the stipulated time.
The complainant in IEBC/DRC/NM/1/2017 alleged
that the candidate presented his nomination papers
to the County Returning Officer (CRO) in time, save
for the delay in presenting the banker’s cheque
occasioned by a breakdown of the banker’s cheque
machine in Homa Bay. This, it was indicated, forced
the candidate to pursue the services in Rongo
Town, 30 kilometres away from Homa Bay.85 The
candidate claimed that the CRO declined to accept
the fees in cash. In its decision, the DRC pointed
Fredrick Odhiambo Oyugi v Orange Democratic Movement & 2 others [2017] eKLR.
Fredrick Odhiambo Oyugi v Orange Democratic Movement & 2 others [2017] eKLR.
Leadership and Integrity Act 19 of 2012 sec 13(2).
As above.
Aluochier v Kenyatta & 4 Others IEBC/DRC/NM. http://kenyalaw.org/kl/fileadmin/pdfdownloads/2017ElectionPetition/Application_by_Isaac_Aluoch_Polo_Aluochier.pdf
Constitution of Kenya art 99(3).
IEBC/DRC/NM/1/2017 Shem Odongo Ochuodho vs. Michael Kosgei Homabay County Returning Officer.
35
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents