up to them to decide how they will proceed, and
there is no rule that fairness always requires an
oral hearing.133 The DRC has opined that, subject
to other rules of natural justice, it can dispense
with an oral hearing if the documents on record
are sufficient for adjudicating a complaint.134 In the
EDR context, given the role of dispute resolution
in meeting democracy, there is no justification to
dismiss cases solely on grounds of non-attendance
of complainants. The complaints lodged at IEBC
and PPDT include affidavits and submissions; in the
event that complainants are unable to be in court for
one reason or another to prosecute their cases, these
documents should be relied upon by the adjudicating
body. The goal is to enable access to justice.
IN THE EDR CONTEXT,
GIVEN THE ROLE OF
DISPUTE RESOLUTION IN
MEETING DEMOCRACY,
THERE IS NO JUSTIFICATION
TO DISMISS CASES
SOLELY ON GROUNDS
OF NON-ATTENDANCE
OF COMPLAINANTS
OPERATIONAL AND
TECHNICAL CONSIDERATIONS
There are critical considerations that EDR
bodies ought to put in place before adjudicating
complaints. They include technical and logistical
structures that contribute to lightening the workload
of EDR bodies. The cases lodged are likely to be
many and complex, yet the resources available
may be limited. Beyond solving disputes, EDR
bodies have a duty to ensure that litigants have an
opportunity to present their cases. It is in this regard
that timely preparation is key.
Factors of note include:
• A functional Case Management System (CMS):
The IEBC acquired a CMS for various functions,
including development of cause lists, filing
complaints, and recording decisions, but the
system was acquired close to the dispute
resolution period, and due to the lean staff, it was
used only for development of cause lists. It would
have contributed to efficiency of the committees
by offering quick access to information, audit
trails, and ease of recordkeeping.
• Devolution of DRC:
The IEBC intended devolution of the DRC and
establishment of two types of panels for settling
disputes; stationary and roving panels. The
decisions to either devolve DRC or establish
two panels did not see the light of day, so all
complaints are adjudicated in Nairobi. This
had an adverse effect on aggrieved persons,
who could not afford travelling and sustaining
themselves in Nairobi as they waited to be heard.
This factor contributed to dismissal of cases on
the basis of non-attendance.
• Legal Support Network:
The IEBC used a list of prequalified lawyers to
identify counsel to offer legal technical support
in conjunction with its in-house lawyers. Their
functions included research on legal issues,
recording court proceedings, and developing
draft Rulings for the IEBC´s interrogation, review,
and approval. This contributed to expeditious
decision making.
• Appropriate venue:
The venue for hearing the cases was Milimani
Law Courts in Nairobi, on the ground floor, due to
its spaciousness to accommodate the media and
133 R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal ex-parte Jones [1988] I WLR 477, 481.
134 Muriuki v Macharia IEBC/DRC/NM/02/2018.
41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents