that the irregularities or electoral malpractices
occurred, it must go further. It must make a
finding on the question whether the irregularities
or electoral malpractices were of such a nature
and effect that they substantially undermined
the ability of the electoral body to deliver a free,
fair and credible election. Section 177 of the Act
provides that, where the ground for seeking
invalidation of an election is commission of a
mistake or non-compliance with the provisions
of the Act, it must appear to the court, after proof
of the mistake or non-compliance, that as a
result thereof the election was not conducted in
accordance with the principles laid down in the
Act and that such mistake or non-compliance did
affect the result of the election.42
A 2019 Afrobarometer survey in Zimbabwe
indicated that, for the majority of people, their
political decisions are affected by experiences or
threats of political violence. When one analyses
the ACLED database, it shows that in Zimbabwe,
incidences of violence spike up during elections.
This may indicate that the violence is systematic,
linked to major political events aimed at influencing
electoral outcomes.
On the question of violence, the court stated that
the applicant did not place this evidence before it.
However, the principle was clear that even if such
evidence had been put before it, it would have to
be such that the transgression affected the result of
the election.
Burchard and Simati43 state that successfully
challenging an election outcome in the courts is
related to a reduction in the lethality of violence
in the next election, but only if the courts are
generally perceived as trustworthy. Burchard and
Simati conclude that in addition, building judicial
capability and improving generalized trust in judicial
institutions is key to reducing electoral violence.
Burchard and Simati quote from a similar research
study by Simati,44 looking at the effect of courts on
This approach is problematic in many ways. First, it
sets the bar for what is wrong and not what is right.
In relation to human rights, courts are expected
to provide the measure for good and give leaders
a greater degree of responsibility in ensuring the
protection of rights. Courts are expected to show
zero tolerance to violence and electoral manipulation.
Allowing a minimum level of violence in an election
creates no incentive for respect for human rights.
Rather, it creates an incentive for continuance of
violence. What is more, the court also decided that
where allegations of a criminal nature are made,
the applicant bears the heavy onus of proving his
case to the higher standard applied in criminal courts,
beyond a reasonable doubt. There is no reason why
such a standard must be applied in election petitions,
which are by their nature civil cases. Instead, the timehonoured principle that civil cases must be decided
on a balance of probabilities should surely apply in
election petitions.
41
42
43
44
60
Chamisa and 24 Others v Emmerson Mnangagwa, CCZ 42-18.
As above 65.
Burchard and Simati (n 6 above) 123-144.
As above 132.
ROLE OF COURTS IN PROMOTING
DEMOCRATIC PARTICIPATION
What role, then, can courts play in positively
influencing the reduction of violence ahead of
an election?
electoral violence conducted cross-nationally on
African countries between 1990-2012. This study
found that variation in judicial independence can
influence both state actors and the opposition’s
choice to employ post-election violence, and that
both the incumbent and the opposition are less
likely to employ post-election violence in African
countries that have independent judiciaries.
However, in the absence of a trusted court system,
political actors are more likely to revert to electoral
violence either to influence the outcome of an
election or in reaction to a concluded election.
Where courts are reluctant to condemn violence,
as in the Buhera North petition, political actors
are most likely to offend against and political
opponents who feel they have no judicial recourse
are most likely to reciprocate with violence.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents