winning a political party nomination in some parties could virtually bring one to electoral victory.6 Political parties in Kenya are required by law to have their own internal dispute resolution mechanisms,7 with the right of appeal to the quasijudicial Political Party Disputes Tribunal,8 or less commonly to the electoral management body, the Independent Boundaries and Electoral Commission (IEBC).9 Indeed, there have been, in the past, instances of jurisdictional overlap and clashes between the IEBC and the Political Parties Dispute Tribunal. This is because the law appeared to vest both bodies with jurisdiction to handle pre-election disputes, thus encouraging forum shopping among litigants. This has since been settled by subsequent legislation and court pronouncements.10 Decisions of the electoral body and the tribunal are still subject to the High Court’s supervisory and judicial review powers if they merit such further input. In effect, various judicial and quasi-judicial bodies other than the election court have a significant influence on the electoral process before voting day. Occasionally, in election dispute petitions that challenge electoral results, issues that would otherwise have been canvassed and adjudicated by the electoral body or the Political Parties Dispute Tribunal during a pre-election period are raised in election courts as a challenge to the results by petitioners for the first time. During adjudication of such election petitions, disputes have arisen in election courts regarding the timing of, and jurisdiction over, such issues. This is as to whether it is proper for a petitioner to fail to raise what are essentially pre-election issues before the mandated institutions and then wait to raise them for the first time at the election court. Although there had been varied debates on the subject, the Supreme Court of Kenya has since put an end to the debate. This 6 7 8 9 10 11 has been done by formulating guiding principles on when pre-election disputes may be entertained by an election court. This was done in the case of Sammy Ndung’u Waity vs. Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 3 others.11 In this case, the Supreme Court of Kenya held that because pre-election disputes relating to nominations or eligibility go to the root of an election and can determine whether a petitioner succeeds or not, an election court can entertain pre-election disputes while determining an election petition. However, such pre-election disputes must be such that the petitioner was unaware of the facts forming the basis of the dispute or could not have been aware of them even upon exercise of due diligence, so as not to have raised them in a pre-election dispute body. Against this backdrop of the significance of the pre-election environment in electoral democracy, this chapter explores the relatively understudied area of pre-election disputes resolution. In particular, the chapter considers the role and functions of the various pre-election bodies, including the internal mechanisms of political parties, the electoral body, the Political Party Disputes Tribunal, and the election court, insofar as it determines pre-election issues. STRUCTURE OF CHAPTER This chapter is divided into five parts. Part one is this INTRODUCTION. Part two reviews the LEGAL AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR RESOLUTION OF PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES in Kenya. Part three ventures to analyse EMERGING JURISPRUDENCE FROM THE ABOVE HIGHLIGHTED PRE-ELECTION DISPUTE RESOLUTION BODIES and consider their impact on free and fair elections in a constitutional democracy. Part four is the CONCLUSION. FO Wanyama & J Elklit, ‘Electoral violence during party primaries in Kenya’ (2018) 25(6) Democratization 1016. The authors argue that the intra-party violence associated with party primaries (political party nominations in Kenya) is a result of the nature of organization of political parties, which are organised around prominent political personalities who are identified with ethno-regional interests. The authors further argue that the intense competition for nomination tickets in these ethno-regional dominant political parties is because winning such tickets virtually guarantees electoral victory. Political Parties Act 11 of 2011, sec 9, second schedule, paragraph 23. Political Parties Act 11 of 2011, sec 40. Constitution of Kenya 2010, art. 88(4) e. See for instance ODM v Edick Omondi Anyanga & Another EPA 126 of 2017 [2017] eKLR. Sammy Ndung’u Waity vs. Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 3 others [2019] eKLR, paras 62-98. One aspect of this challenge to the results of a governor’s election was the petitioner’s argument that the successful candidate was not lawfully nominated. The petitioner argued this was because he did not meet the criteria for being an independent candidate, having too recently resigned as a member of the Jubilee Party when he was unsuccessful in their primary election. The petitioner lost the appeal as the court found he was in possession of the relevant facts and could have brought his challenge before the election. 65

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents