minorities and marginalised groups; respecting and
promoting human rights and fundamental freedoms,
and gender equality and equity; and promoting the
objects and principles of the Constitution and the
rule of law.
The Political Parties Dispute Tribunal (PPDT) is
established under Section 39 of the Political Parties
Act of 2011 and is made up of members appointed
by the Judicial Service Commission. The Tribunal is
an external dispute resolution mechanism following
the exhaustion of internal party mechanisms. The
mandates of the Tribunal in law are to hear and
determine disputes between a member and a
political party, between members of a political party,
between political parties, between an independent
candidate and a political party, between coalition
partners, appeals from decisions of the Registrar
of Political Parties; and disputes arising out of
party primaries.40 All this exercise of jurisdiction by
the Tribunal where one of the parties is a political
party or a member of political party is subject to
exhaustion of internal party mechanisms, except
for disputes involving independent candidates and
those arising out of party primaries, which may
be taken directly to the Tribunal. The Tribunal is
required to determine the above disputes within
a period of three months following the lodging of
such dispute.41 Decisions of the Tribunal may be
enforced in the same manner as those made by
a Magistrates Court. In addition, an appeal lies
from the Tribunal to the High Court on matters of
fact and law, with a further appeal to the Court of
Appeal and Supreme Court on issues of law only.42
Further, the First Schedule to the Act contains a
Code of Conduct for Political Parties. Although
not being strictly prescriptive as to the contents
of parties’ constitutions, the Second Schedule
contains the Contents of Parties’ Constitution or
Rules to ensure that such rules cover important
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
72
issues. The Third Schedule of the Act sets out the
basic requirements of a coalition agreement, given
the ubiquity of political coalitions among political
parties to capture political power.
The courts have been clear that pre-election
disputes including nomination disputes must be
resolved by the pre-election dispute resolution
bodies, which include political parties’ internal
dispute resolution mechanisms, the IEBC, and
the Political Party Disputes Tribunal. Once these
forums are exhausted, a pre-election issue
including nomination disputes may reach an
election court. Despite divided judicial opinion
over this jurisdictional issue,43 the Court of Appeal
has clarified the matter. This was in the case of
Kennedy Moki v Rachel Kaki Nyamai & 2 others.44
The Court clarified that nominations are part of
an election process and that an election may be
challenged only by way of an election petition
following declaration of results. Based on this, an
election court can entertain what were essentially
pre-election issues including nomination disputes.45
Providing judicial construction to Article 88(4)(e) of
the Constitution, the Court of Appeal held that this
constitutional provision does not in any way oust
the jurisdiction of an election court with respect to
nomination disputes.46 In addition, a person may
approach the High Court under Articles 22 and
23 of the Constitution by couching a dispute as
one involving a violation of the constitutional right
to vote or exercise of any of their political rights
provided for under Article 38 of the Constitution
in the Bill of Rights. In such cases, the Court
would be sitting not as an election court but as a
constitutional court, and with a more expansive
jurisdiction to deal with many issues. These include
procurement of electoral materials and other
disenfranchisement practices that can affect the
outcome of an election, as illustrated in the next
section on emerging jurisprudence.
Section 40.
Section 41(1).
Section 41(2).
See example, Charles Ong’ondo Were v Joseph Oyugi Magwanga & 2 Others, Homa Bay Election Petition 1 of 2013 where the Court held that an election court has no jurisdiction over
pre-election issues while the converse was held in William Odhiambo Oduol v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 2 Others Kisumu Election Petition 2 of 2013.
Kennedy Moki v Rachel Kaki Nyamai & 2 others [2018] eKLR.
As above para 57.
As above para 58.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents