was owing to the party’s exercise of discretion to issue a direct nomination, which was done in conformity with the party’s rules. However, when considered in light of the provisions of Article 91 of the Constitution, which requires political parties to uphold democratic principles and conduct free and fair elections, it is difficult to argue that this was achieved. In our view, the discretion to issue direct tickets to nominees ought to be exercised sparingly and only in exceptional cases as per parties’ constitutions, because it is amenable to abuse by powerful political players to the exclusion of other candidates. Potentially, such a position can create perverse incentives for political party elites to favour their preferred candidates, even where such candidates are not popular with the electorate. In this regard, this has the potential to shield some candidates from being subjected to normal nomination and election processes that are the hallmark of free and fair elections. POTENTIALLY, SUCH A POSITION CAN CREATE PERVERSE INCENTIVES FOR POLITICAL PARTY ELITES TO FAVOUR THEIR PREFERRED CANDIDATES Indeed, the Political Parties Dispute Tribunal has on other occasions emphasized the importance of ensuring that political parties are guided by Article 91 of the Constitution. This is in addition to being bound by democratic principles and rules of natural justice in nominations even where the party rules allow for direct nomination. For instance, in Elijah Omondi v Orange Democratic Movement & Another,54 the PPDT stated thus at paragraphs 9 and 10: We note that Article 91 of the Constitution, which establishes political parties as agencies of the democratic process, requires political parties 54 55 56 to abide by the principles of good governance and democracy. They must also promote the principles and objects of the Constitution including the national values and principles of governance. We agree with the Claimant and hold that the current Constitution engenders a culture of justification in which every decision by a political party must be justified. The culture of justification demands that a political party must supply an affected person with the reasons for the party’s decision. It is only by supplying reasons that it can be ascertained whether or not the decision is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society. Moreover, in Joshua Wakahora Irungu v Jubilee Party & another,55 the PPDT overturned the decision of the National Appeals Tribunal (NAT) of the party, which had found that nomination in a constituency was irregular and nullified the results. The NAT failed to order fresh nominations for that constituency, but instead excluded the results of that constituency and determined the winner based on results of the remaining two constituencies in that county. The NAT had justified this decision on the basis of the doctrine of necessity. It held that owing to time constraints, there was no time to conduct fresh nominations in time for presentation of the nominees to the electoral body. This was despite clear provisions in the party’s rules requiring the holding of fresh nominations upon nullification of results. Noting that doing so had disenfranchised the people of the particular constituency and was irregular and unjustified, the PPDT held that fresh nominations ought to have been conducted. In the PPDT’s view, even time constraints could not suffice to justify contravention of the express provisions of the Constitution, especially the right of the electorate to elect a representative of their choice. According to the European Union Election Observation Mission Report56 on the 2017 Kenyan general elections, the PPDT played a more significant role than in prior periods. The PPDT Elijah Omondi v Orange Democratic Movement & Another Complaint 251 of 2017. [Not available online, though it is cited in other published decisions]. Joshua Wakahora Irungu v Jubilee Party & another Complaint 62 of 2017. http://www.kenyalaw.org/tribunals/PoliticalTribunal/Joshua_Wakahora_Irungu_v_Jubilee_Party_&_ another_%5B2017%5D_eKLR.pdf EU EOM, Final Report General Elections Kenya 2017 (January 2018) <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/cmsdata/212568/Kenya-general-elections_2017_EU-EOM-report.pdf > accessed 01 March 2021. 75

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents