adjudicated more than 306 cases relating to party
primaries and 235 cases relating to political party
lists and out of these, 117 were appealed to the
High Court, 32 to the Court of Appeal and two
of the cases were appealed all the way to the
Supreme Court.57 The Tribunal also ordered a rerun
of party nominations in at least eight cases and
reconstitution of at least 19 party lists for failure
to comply with the constitutional requirements of
considering the marginalised categories.58
ROLE OF THE IEBC IN SUBMISSION OF
PARTY LISTS BY POLITICAL PARTIES
Other disputes at the PPDT involved the submission
of party lists to the IEBC as Article 177 (1)(c) requires
for nominations to represent special interests and
the marginalised. In Margaret Adhiambo Oketch
v Orange Democratic Movement,59 the PPDT
considered a claim of such nature whereby the
claimant contested the party list that had been
submitted to the IEBC. Adhiambo claimed that her
name as a nominee to represent the disabled had
been omitted from the final list. Although she did
not lead evidence at the PPDT to prove that her
name had been omitted, the PPDT made important
pronouncements with respect to the law relating
to preparation and submission of party lists to the
IEBC. Acknowledging that indeed it is the domain
of political parties to prepare party lists, the PPDT
was emphatic that the IEBC retains an oversight
role over parties for the purpose of ensuring
compliance with the Constitution, the law, and
the party’s own rules.60 The PPDT stated that the
IEBC may require a party to amend its party list to
ensure that it complies with the law, meaning that
whereas political parties have the right to prepare
party lists, they do not have the final say. This
supervisory and oversight role afforded by law to
the IEBC in scrutinizing party lists to determine their
compliance with constitutional principles ensures
that political parties do not abuse their discretion,
thereby expanding the democratic space.
57
58
59
60
61
62
76
EXERCISE OF POLITICAL RIGHTS
TO VIE VERSUS PARTY HOPPING
OR PARTY DISCIPLINE
Some cases have challenged infringement
of the rights of voters. This was the case in
Joshua Wakahora Irungu v Jubilee Party &
another Constitutional Petition No. 56 of 2017.61
This constitutional petition challenged the
constitutionality of an amendment to the Elections
Act that had the effect of restricting party hopping
by a candidate after losing in the party nominations.
The petitioner argued that this, in effect, infringed
his constitutional right to associate and stand for
election in a party of his choice. Although this was a
constitutional court determining a petition alleging
infringement of constitutional rights rather than
an election court, it made important findings that
impact on elections in a constitutional democracy.
The court held that the said amendment was
constitutional, as a member of party is not in any
event required to be a member of more than
one political party at the same time and that
nothing prevents an individual from vying as an
independent candidate. The court acknowledged
that the amendment tended to restrict the right or
interests of an individual in vying for an elective
post in a party but held that the restriction was
necessary and justifiable in the public interest
of preventing party hopping and instilling party
discipline. In making this point, the court remarked:
The provision in question advances a compelling
state interest to manage the electoral process
efficiently as opposed to the individual interests
of the petitioners who seem to be interested
in looking for an opportunity to shift party
allegiance after losing nominations. A law aimed
at promoting the legitimate state interest in
fair, honest and orderly elections is in my view
consistent with the provisions of the constitution
that require elections to be credible.62
As above 15.
As above.
Complaint No. 381 of 2017. http://www.kenyalaw.org/tribunals/PoliticalTribunal/381_Margaret_Adhiambo_Oketch_v_Orange_Democratic_Movement_[2017] eKLR.pdf (accessed
on13 April 2020).
As above para 7.
Joshua Wakahora Irungu v Jubilee Party & another Constitutional Petition No. 56 of 2017.
As above 11.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents