CONCLUSION
This chapter set out to explore the emerging
jurisprudence on resolution of pre-election disputes
from statute and the various dispute resolution
bodies. This was with a view both to document
the existing knowledge and critique this body of
knowledge. The chapter has discussed the critical
role played by various dispute resolution bodies
and laws that undergird pre-election disputes.
The discussion is premised on the understanding
that an election is a process that commences
before registration of voters and lasts at least until
declaration of results. This is as opposed to the
voting event. Based on this, it has been argued
that the pre-election environment ought to be
afforded more attention that it has in the past. The
chapter began by providing a context into various
pre-election issues that form the subject matter of
disputes. It then ventured into examining the legal
and institutional framework relating to resolution
of pre-election disputes. This was followed with
a review and analysis of various cases from the
various pre-election dispute resolution forums. This
gives the trajectory that electoral jurisprudence
has taken. In the main, it is concluded that the
emerging jurisprudence has clarified the roles and
functions of the various bodies, thus reducing the
jurisdictional overlap that prevailed before. More
fundamentally, many of the decisions made are
a significant step towards improving on the preelection environment and thus, are a positive step
in engendering electoral democracy.
80
IT IS CONCLUDED THAT THE
EMERGING JURISPRUDENCE
HAS CLARIFIED THE
ROLES AND FUNCTIONS
OF THE VARIOUS BODIES,
THUS REDUCING THE
JURISDICTIONAL OVERLAP
THAT PREVAILED BEFORE
The above notwithstanding, it is also noted that
there have been cases where political parties
abuse their discretion and use the internal dispute
resolution mechanisms to privilege favoured
candidates as nominees. This is the case even
where such candidates are not popular with the
electorate. This has happened through the issuance
of direct nominations which are usually allowed in
the parties’ constitutions and consequently affirmed
by either the IEBC or the Political Parties Dispute
Tribunal. In addition, the jurisprudence from some
courts and the PPDT which appear to claim that an
election court cannot inquire into the eligibility of a
candidate to vie, on grounds that the same is the
jurisdiction of pre-election bodies, is bad law, as it
helps to sanction electoral fraud. In addition, there
is need for legislative reforms to set timelines within
which pre-election disputes must be resolved by all
dispute resolution bodies.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents