CHAPTER 6 NULLIFICATION OF ELECTION RESULTS AND THE STANDARD OF PROOF: EMERGING JURISPRUDENCE IN SELECTED SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA COUNTRIES TARISAI MUTANGI* ABSTRACT This chapter is an inquiry into electoral dispute resolution, with particular focus on the emerging jurisprudence on the standard of proof required to annul an election in Africa. The inquiry is premised on the high failure rate of electoral petitions prevalent across the continent. Petitioners find it almost impossible to reverse an election result, based on allegations of electoral malpractice, fraud, or any other grounds allowed by the law of each country. The author makes several findings, one of which is that there is no consensus among sub-Saharan countries whether election proceedings are civil or criminal. This has a bearing on the standard of proof required. Second, there is consensus that the petitioner bears the onus to prove that the election was not conducted in accordance with the law or that there were irregularities and that such irregularities affected the result in a “substantial manner.” This onus may shift to the respondent to rebut the petitioner’s prima facie case, sometimes back and forth between the parties until one of the parties has established an answered case. Third, that there is no consensus on the standard of proof, with some jurisdictions using the balance of probabilities, others proof beyond reasonable doubt while a few use the “intermediate standard.” The latter is between the civil and criminal standards of proof. Fourth, that there is general consensus that an election petition is sui generis, based on its importance to governance and exercise of political power. Other jurisdictions have rejected this approach, in preference of a human rights-based approach that makes the right to vote the primary consideration. The author concludes that there is no basis for elevating election petition proceedings to a level higher than any other proceedings. Where civil allegations are made, the petitioner should prove their case on the civil scale, but where criminal allegations are made, a higher standard is appropriate. * Dr. Tarisai Mutangi is a Senior Lecturer and Head of Department in the Faculty of Law, University of Zimbabwe. He also practices law under the style of DNM Attorneys specialising in Constitutional Litigation. The views expressed herein are his own. 83

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents