adversarial process where the aggrieved person,
on any other person in whom the law vests legal
standing, is entitled to initiate legal proceedings
challenging the result of an election. Invariably, the
complainant is required to place before the court or
tribunal evidence with sufficient probative value to
convince the court to a degree required by law that
certain aspects of the electoral process were not
executed as the law requires. In other instances,
the petitioner alleges misconduct or offences of
criminal nature that altered the outcome of an
election. This means that the result does not reflect
the will of the people who voted. On their part,
respondents also need to pitch plausible defences
to dispel the challenge and affirm the integrity of
the election.
This chapter interrogates the standard of proof
required to overturn an election result in SubSaharan Africa. It explores how judges across
Africa have dealt with the complex question
of standard of proof in the adjudication of
election petitions. The chapter maps the diverse
application and interpretation of standard of proof
in electoral petitions to understand its impact on
the administration of electoral justice in Africa.
The importance of electoral justice cannot be
overstated. The right to vote would be merely
abstract without the opportunity to enforce it in
the courts of law. Challenging the validity of an
election is essentially an act of democratic selfgovernment meant to ensure free, fair, and credible
elections. Preservation of electoral intent and
purity of elections hinges on the effective and
fair adjudication of election grievances. Thus, the
question of standard of proof in electoral cases, which
plays a central role in adjudication of such disputes, is
of paramount importance. The chapter studies various
cases and literature on the notion of standard of proof
and analyses the extent to which such practice is in
tandem with international best practises.
86
STRUCTURE OF CHAPTER
This chapter is a random survey of the practice
of a few countries in Sub-Saharan Africa. They
include Ghana, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Seychelles,
Uganda, Zambia and Zimbabwe, with comparative
references to non-African countries.
The chapter is divided into five parts. Part
one is this INTRODUCTORY SECTION. Part
two discusses the NATURE OF ELECTORAL
PETITION PROCEEDINGS, alluding to some of
the grounds on which these are based. Part three
discusses the BURDEN OF PROOF, determining
the question of who bears the responsibility to
prove or disprove a case. Part four discusses the
notion of STANDARD OF PROOF. The notion is
defined; approaches of different jurisdictions are
presented and discussed, with a synthesis and
analysis given. Part five is the CONCLUSION.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents