THE NATURE OF ELECTORAL PETITION PROCEEDINGS
The issue of standard of proof may not be
adequately investigated without a clear exposition
of the nature of election petition proceedings. One
of the issues is whether an election petition should
be classified as a civil proceeding or as criminal
proceedings. As will be discussed in detail later,
this issue has vexed courts and practitioners alike.
However, the answer to the question draws one
nearer to the conclusion as to the appropriate
standard of proof required to annul an invalid
election. It is trite in the region that civil and criminal
legal proceedings have different standards of
proof. Parties engaged in civil proceedings have
the obligation to prove their cases on a balance
of probabilities, while in criminal proceedings, the
state is required to prove its case beyond reasonable
doubt. The latter standard is generally onerous to
discharge because of the heavy evidentiary burden.
To put context to the discussion, it is important
to note that electoral laws of most countries in
Africa provide for electoral offences. These are
offences committed either by a candidate, voter,
or by the EMB officials. Electoral offences exist
to preserve the integrity or purity of the electoral
process. Criminal sanctions are inherently
deterrent and contribute to the ensuring the
free will of voters. Although some offences are
also founded in tort or delict, many of them are
criminal.15 These include corrupt practices, false
representation when registering as a voter, voting
without the right to do so, and threatening voters
with violence. Other offences include coercing for
support and vote-buying. Many of these offences
form part of the grounds for challenging the
result of an election, such as where the winning
candidate allegedly forged documentation of their
educational qualifications or where votes were
15
16
17
18
19
20
corruptly obtained. Both criminal and non-criminal
allegations could be made in a single petition. This
presents a practical legal difficulty of determining
the nature of proceedings.
MANY OF THESE
OFFENCES FORM PART
OF THE GROUNDS FOR
CHALLENGING THE
RESULT OF AN ELECTION
There are judicial decisions addressing this
difficulty and some consider it settled. Electoral
courts in some jurisdictions have referred to
election petition proceedings as neither civil nor
criminal but sui generis in nature.16 In the Abubakar
case the court held that they were, “in a class by
itself” and that they were “different from a common
law civil action,” and that this legal position “is trite”
and no longer “moot.”17 This view of Nigerian courts
is also shared by Ghanaian courts. In Akuffo-Addo
& Ors v Mahama & Ors,18 quoting with approval
the High Court of Trinidad and Tobago in Peters
v Attorney-General,19 the Court wrote a lengthy
explanation regarding the extent of public interest
in each election petition before concluding that:
An election petition is quite unlike any of the
initiating proceedings in the High Court. It is not
a writ, or originating summons, nor is it in any
way close to say a petition in bankruptcy or a
petition for divorce which respectively have their
own rules of procedure. In a sense, an election
petition can be described as sui generis.20
Common electoral offences based in tort or delict include fraud and other forms of negligence or breach of duty of care.
Translated to mean ‘in a class of its on’.
Available at <https://nigerialii.org/ng/judgment/supreme-court/2008/10-17> (accessed on 10 March 2020).
Writ No. J1/6/2013.
(2002) 3 LRC 32 C.A.
As above 101.
87
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents