BURDEN OF PROOF IN ELECTION PETITIONS
One of the key issues that courts considering
election disputes have to confront is determining
who bearers the burden of proof/persuasion.38
Every finalised election is protected by a
presumption of its validity.39 The Supreme Court of
Kenya asserted that this presumption has origins
from a long-standing common law approach in
respect of alleged irregularity in the acts of public
bodies. The maxim that all acts are presumed to
have been done rightly and regularly applies here.40
Thus, the petitioner, “must set out by raising firm
and credible evidence of the public authority’s
departures from the prescriptions of the law.”41 The
emerging philosophy is that an election reflects
the free will of voters, more importantly because
voting and related rights are constitutional rights
collectively referred to as political rights. A great
deal of resources are deployed to facilitate the
holding of a free and fair election. Such is the
sacrifice that makes people cherish democracy and
stirs immense public interest. This is heightened in
a presidential election, where the whole territory is
the constituency of voters.
Therefore, setting aside an election requires
production of cogent evidence to prove that the
whole process [conduct of a public body] was a
farce and voters did not express their free will. It
follows that one or more of the parties should carry
this burden to prove that there were irregularities
(non-compliance with the law) or that electoral
offences (malpractices) were committed. They must
also prove that such non-compliance or offences
violated the free will of voters, which affected the
election “in a substantial manner.”
38
39
40
41
42
43
90
The electoral laws of every country provide for
causes of action on which an electoral challenge
should founded. These are the permissible grounds
for challenging the result of an election. There
seems to be consistency in terms of permissible
grounds across the region. The grounds include
non-compliance with electoral laws and victory by a
candidate not qualified to stand for office. This is in
addition to commission of electoral offences. Some
jurisdictions restrict these grounds, whereas others
maintain an open-ended list by deploying the
language of “or any other cause whatsoever.”42
THE PARTY WITH BURDEN OF PROOF
In conventional civil litigation, the litigant who
alleges or the plaintiff, must prove the allegation
supported by evidence of probative value. The
common law concept of burden of proof (onus
probandi) is a question of law. It is best described
as the duty to establish a case or the facts upon
a particular issue.43 Bearing the burden of proof
carries a positive obligation. Requiring the
respondent or defendant to prove allegations
would impose a negative burden, which would be
difficult to discharge. Rebuttal of allegations is less
onerous, as it serves to cast doubt on the plaintiff’s
allegations. In criminal proceedings, the defence
case serves to cast doubt on the state case,
thereby entitling the accused person to an acquittal
on the grounds of reasonable doubt.
In Sub-Saharan Africa, the majority of countries are
hesitant to subject these proceedings to the usual
rules of civil procedure. In fact, several countries
Nana Addo Dankwa Akufo Addo & 2 others v. John Dramani Mahama & 2 others WRIT No. J 1/6/2013, p 57. In terms of Section 10 of the Ghanaian Evidence Act, 1975, burden of
persuasion entails a party having the obligation ‘… to establish a requisite degree of belief concerning a fact in the mind of the tribunal of fact or the Court’ while Section 11 of the
defines burden of evidence as ‘the burden of producing evidence means the obligation of a party to introduce sufficient evidence to avoid a ruling against him on the issue’.
See decisions of Kenyan Court of Appeal in George Mike Wanjohi v. Steven Kariuki & 2 Others Petition No. 2A of 2014; [2014] eKLR; Supreme Court of Ghana in Nana Addo
Dankwa Akufo Addo & 2 others v. John Dramani Mahama & 2 others WRIT No. J 1/6/2013.
In Latin the maxim is: omnia praesumuntur rite et solemniter esse acta.
Raila Odinga & 5 Others v. Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 Others, Petition No. 5 of 2013; [2013] eKLR, para 195 - 196. The presumption of validity of an
election (official duty) is codified in section 37 of the Ghanaian Evidence Act, 1975.
See section 100 of the Malawian Presidential and Parliamentary Elections Act, 2005; sections 167 of the Zimbabwean Electoral Act, 2005.
Auburn J, ‘Burden of Proof’ in Malik H (ed), Phipson on Evidence, 17th (ed), 2010, p 149–151.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents