Commissioners resign from the IEBC, leaving only
the Chairperson and two members, which is still the
current status, mean the IEBC cannot constitute a
valid committee. That said, during by-elections, the
IEBC purportedly constituted an ECCEC even when
it did not have sufficient members. It is nevertheless
instructive that the court held on a different issue
that the IEBC has the mandate to conduct elections,
the issue of enforcement of the code did not
arise.36 The strain on the Commissioners would be
addressed by operationalising the Peace Committees
and reducing the quorum of the ECCEC to three
members through a legislative amendment.
in elections. The IEBC’s jurisdiction to adjudicate
these disputes is drawn from Article 88(4)(e) of the
Constitution and Section 74 of the Elections Act.
The law demands that once lodged, disputes have
to be determined within 10 days of the lodging, but
if they relate to prospective nomination or election,
they must be determined before the respective
dates. The rationale is to ensure expeditious
resolution of disputes to allow aggrieved parties
an opportunity to contest elections. The Dispute
Resolution Committee (DRC) comprises at least
three members of the IEBC; the composition is not
provided by a Statute but by the IEBC.
As observed earlier, a significant number of matters
were dismissed for want of prosecution, which
includes non-attendance of complainants. Due
to the cost and time required to travel to Nairobi
and the financial strain on the complainants,
some did not manage to be present to prosecute
their complaints. Operationalisation of Peace
Committees would be a step in the right direction,
as disputes would be addressed at the grassroots
level, if local people were to serve on the
committees; legislative interventions would be
required for this, however. In a report produced in
October 2020, the IEBC said that it appreciated
the challenges to enforcing the Code including
the membership and the qualifications of the
chairperson of the ECCEC.37 The Code has also
Disputes regarding nomination of candidate include
allegations of an independent candidate being a
member of a political party because he had failed to
resign from a political party within the stipulated three
months’ period, that a political party candidate or an
independent candidate did not have all the necessary
qualifications including presentation of invalid
documents, invalid party nomination processes, and
that a party candidate is not a member of a political
party. The law does not provide an exhaustive list of
grounds on which complaints are based but the IEBC
is at liberty to entertain any complaint as long as it
raises triable issues.41
been painted as ineffective with respect to punishing
perpetrators of violence against women.38
DISPUTES ARISING OUT OF NOMINATIONS
The IEBC’s mandate to register candidates for
elections is spelt out in the Constitution.39 The
Elections Act echoes the Constitutional provisions
and refers to nomination as meaning submission
to the IEBC of the name of a candidate.40 It is at
this point that Returning Officers interact with
political parties, political parties’ candidates, and
independent candidates to determine participation
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
In 2017, the IEBC DRC heard and determined 350
disputes arising from decisions of the Returning
Officers to register candidates for elections from
4 to 13 June 2017.42 Save for the cited IEBC postelection evaluation report that appreciated the
challenges faced during the dispute resolution
period, at the point of writing this paper, I did not
come across a report on the outcome of the cases
or the scorecard of the IEBC.
Kangwonyi v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & another [2018] eKLR http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/157852/
Electoral Law Reform: the IEBC experience https://www.iebc.or.ke/uploads/resources/y3m5nIJjMI.pdf (accessed 26 February 2021).
As above.
Constitution of Kenya art 88(4) (f).
Elections Act 24 of 2011 sec 2.
Rules of Procedure on Settlement of Disputes L.N 139/2012 rule 9.
Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Post Election Report https://www.iebc.or.ke/uploads/resources/V9UUoGqVBK.pdf (pg 106) (accessed 28 February 2021).
29
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents