There was no dispute on the failure of political
parties to submit comprehensive party lists nor
the failure of IEBC to enforce this requirement.
According to the Constitution, every political party
is required to submit 98 party lists; 47 gender topup lists for the 47 counties, 47 marginalised lists for
the 47 counties, a list of 12 nominated persons to
the National Assembly, and 3 lists for the Senate
of 16 women, two youth, and two persons with
disabilities.118 Although the stated constitutional
provision is couched in mandatory terms, the IEBC
allowed parties to choose whether to submit all 98
party lists. Regardless of the practicability of the
policy decision, entities which should implement
laws cannot decide if and when to operate within
the confines of laws. Failure by a party to submit
party lists means that it forfeits its benefits if
it emerges after an election that it could have
been entitled to allocation of special seats had it
submitted the lists. Still, the repercussions are not
aligned with the need to ensure representation of
special-interest groups. The IEBC should not be
party to this; the law should be amended to state
that political parties need not submit all 98 lists.
The Narok Election Petition 6 of 2017, Sialo Natanya
Tasur and another v IEBC and others is a product of
the MCCP’s failure to submit a comprehensive list
for Narok County.119 It emerged that had the party
nomination rules of the political party that submitted
it.122 The DRC therefore held that Jubilee Party
had a duty to develop a party list that respects its
own rules, and that the rules created a legitimate
expectation that a Nakuru County party list was
limited to persons registered in Nakuru County.
The complaint raised several questions, including
whether qualifications for single majority seats
apply to the special seats. Was this a sound
trajectory? Political parties have a duty to adhere to
constitutional and statutory provisions.123 In turn, in
developing their constitutions and rules, they must
uphold all laws, and avoid introducing rules that
limit either the Constitution or the Elections Act of
2011. It may be argued that special-interest seats
at the county level aim to reflect the composition
of the county and therefore should be confined
to persons registered as voters in the respective
county. However, limiting rights of other voters
through a party constitution does not satisfy
the limitation conditions under Article 24 of
the Constitution.
submitted a comprehensive list for Narok County, it
could have been allocated a special seat.
Consequently, Parliament enacted the Election
Campaign Financing Act of 2013 for various
purposes, including regulation of contributions and
expenditure.125 The Election Campaign Financing
Act of 2013 was not implemented for purposes of
the 2017 general election, as it was suspended by
Parliament.126 The absence of campaign financing
rules at least 12 months before an election, as
required under Section 5 of the Election Campaign
Financing Act, was among the reasons for
suspension. The IEBC had, however, made steps
towards implementation, including gazettement of
contribution and expenditure limits.127 There was
therefore no pre-election dispute on this issue.
The issue of voter registration arose before
the DRC in connection with a party list.120 The
complainant alleged that the party list submitted by
Jubilee Party for Nakuru County included nominees
who were not registered within Nakuru County,
contrary to the Jubilee Party’s nomination rules.
The DRC bench observed that if a registered voter
is qualified to be a member of a county assembly,
the electoral area of registration is immaterial.121
It nevertheless noted that a party list submitted
to the IEBC must conform to the constitution and
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
CAMPAIGN FINANCING
The IEBC has the mandate to regulate he amount
of money that may be spent by or on behalf of a
candidate or party in respect of any election.124
Constitution of Kenya art 90 (2) (a).
Kapasar v Sialo Natanya Tasur & Ors Election Petition Appeal 2 of 2018 [2018] eKLR. http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/157972/
Gikonyo v Jubilee Party and IEBC, IEBC/NM/PL/20/2017.
Elections Act 24 of 2011 sec 25.
Elections Act 24 of 2011 sec 34(6).
Political Parties Act 11 of 2011 First Schedule para 5& 6 (b).
Constitution of Kenya art 88 (4) (i).
Election Campaign Financing Act 42 of 2013 sec 12 & 18.
Election Campaign Financing Act 42 of 2013 sec 1A.
As above.
39
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents