PRE-ELECTION ENVIRONMENT PILLARS
MECHANISMS FOR DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Elections are a major driver of disputes, some of
which escalate into “electoral violence.” Violence
becomes “electoral violence” because of its
timing, goals, and outcomes.3 It can be direct
(physical harm), but it can also be cultural (like
hate speech). Violence can also be structural (like
failure by the police to bring perpetrators to book,
thus spurring impunity). One of the most critical
aspects of the pre-election environment is how
societies design methods of resolving conflicts
peacefully and effectively to avoid falling into
violence. Although investments in transparency,
institutional capacity, and impartial coverage are
important, these do not eliminate the occasion of
conflict and the associated risks. This is the reality
of every human venture. It is therefore critical that
in the pre-election period, mechanisms be put in
place to ensure continuous resolution of disputes
peacefully. This includes preventive methods like a
Code of Conduct that prohibits hate speech.
ONE OF THE MOST CRITICAL
ASPECTS OF THE PREELECTION ENVIRONMENT
IS HOW SOCIETIES DESIGN
METHODS OF RESOLVING
CONFLICTS PEACEFULLY
AND EFFECTIVELY TO AVOID
FALLING INTO VIOLENCE
To take the example of Zimbabwe, it has put in
place a dispute resolution mechanism specifically
related to elections. This mechanism is centred
3
4
5
50
around the drafting of specific laws and procedures,
for adjudication by the courts. The mechanism
is set up under provisions of the Constitution of
Zimbabwe Amendment (No.20) Act 2013, as well
as the Electoral Act. Section 93 of the Constitution
sets out the procedure for handling disputes
emerging from a presidential election. Section 161
of the Electoral Act [Chapter 2:13] established the
Electoral Court to deal specifically with election
disputes and review the decisions of the Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission (ZEC). The Constitution,
Electoral Act, Electoral Court Rules, and the
Constitutional Court Rules read together constitute
a compass that guides the Electoral Court and the
Constitutional Court in relation to procedure in
electoral petitions before these Courts. This is in
addition to the form which the petitions themselves
must adopt as well as the miscellany incidental to
the prosecution of an election petition in Zimbabwe.4
In the case of Makamure v. Mutongwiza & Ors,5 the
court made the following observations:
As the citizens of this country begin to exercise
their democratic rights in the arena of electoral
law, it is more than likely that there will be a
dramatic increase in the number of election
petitions. They will require, for their just resolution,
the holding of election trials spanning several days
and even weeks and to be heard expeditiously.
This effectiveness of the judiciary necessarily
brings other issues into sharp focus, such as its
independence, in the judicial appointment process
and in their continuing tenure. This is in addition to
such issues as the judiciary’s capacity to resolve the
disputes in a timely manner, depending on training,
available human resources, and efficient case
management procedures. Nonetheless, the role
UNDP ‘Report on Elections, Violence and Conflict Prevention’ ( 2011) 17. http://aceproject.org/electoral-advice/archive/questions/replies/190117228/266390805/Elections-Violenceand-Conflict-Prevention.pdf.
T Mutangi ‘An Overview of the Practice and Procedure When Litigating Election Petitions in Zimbabwe’ (2019) para 4, <https://zimlii.org/content/overview-practice-and-procedurewhen-litigating-election-petitions-zimbabwe>.
1998 (2) ZLR 154.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents