EMERGING JURISPRUDENCE ON PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES
This section reviews decisions made by the various
dispute resolution forums discussed in the foregoing
section and provides a critique of the jurisprudence
with respect to its impact on democracy.
ROLE OF POLITICAL PARTIES IN
ELECTORAL DEMOCRACY AND
RESOLUTION OF PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES
In Denis Wafula Okinda v Linus Ouma Asiba & 5
others,47 the complainant was an aspirant in the
third defendant’s party nominations for position
of Member of County Assembly. He claimed that
he had been declared winner in the nominations
and consequently issued with a provisional
nomination certificate as the valid winner. His
nomination certificate was, however, nullified
following a challenge by the first Defendant at the
party’s Internal Dispute Resolution Mechanism,
which also barred the complainant from further
political activities on grounds of having caused
violence. Further, the party’s internal mechanism
had directed the returning officer to issue the
nomination certificate to the first defendant instead.
The Political Parties Dispute Tribunal, after finding
that the claimant had been afforded a fair hearing
in which he refused to participate even after due
notice of hearing, upheld the decision of the party’s
internal dispute resolution mechanism. This was on
the finding of violence and subsequent revocation
of the nomination certificate. In dismissing the
complainant’s claim, the Tribunal affirmed that
the party’s internal dispute resolution mechanism
gave effect to the right to a fair hearing with the
opportunity to be heard.
The Wafula Okinda case should be contrasted
with Caroli Omondi v Hon. John Mbadi & 2
Others.48 In that case, the complainant successfully
challenged the decision of the party to declare
the first respondent the winner of the nominations
47
48
for Member of Parliament at the party’s National
Appeals Tribunal (NAT). The NAT found that the
nomination exercise could not have been said
to have been above board and consequently
proceeded to nullify the nomination results.
Based on this, the NAT revoked the award of
nomination certificate to the first respondent. The
NAT further ordered the National Elections Board
to conduct fresh nominations. The complainant,
being dissatisfied with the decision of the NAT to
call for fresh nominations, filed an appeal to the
Political Parties Dispute Tribunal. In the appeal,
the complainant sought for fresh tallying of results
instead of fresh nominations. The complainant
argued that the NAT had erred in its definition of
what constituted ballot stuffing. He urged the NAT
to adopt a definition which defined the practice
as fraud, whereby a person who is permitted to
vote submits multiple votes. The complainant
sought refuge under Regulation 83 of the Elections
(General) Regulations 2012. It was argued that
given that the votes cast exceeded the registered
voters in the area, the NAT ought to order a retally of the nomination results. This was to be by
disregarding results from seven polling stations
marred with irregularities and proceeding to
declare the complainant the winner. In the response
to the claim, the first Respondent submitted that,
in compliance with the NAT decision to cancel
the nomination and call for fresh nominations, the
party decided to issue direct nomination to him,
which is allowed under the party’s constitution
and rules. The third respondent, the Orange
Democratic Movement, also claimed that the party
had opted to issue a direct nomination to the first
respondent. This was because he was an important
member of the party and that timelines to submit
nominated candidates to the electoral body were
fast approaching. It was only with this that time
would allow the conduct of fresh party primaries.
The third respondent claimed that party primaries
[2017] eKLR, Complaint No. 24 of 2017. http://www.kenyalaw.org/tribunals/PoliticalTribunal/Denis_Wafula_Okinda_v_Linus_Ouma_Asiba_&_5_others_%5b2017%5d_eKLR.pdf
(accessed on 12 April 2020).
[2017] eKLR, Complaint No. 42 of 2017.
73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents