under the Political Parties Act 2011 could either be
an “election or selection” and that either of them
sufficed for purposes of party primaries. In the
circumstances, the respondents argued that the
complainant’s challenge to the new nomination
process ought to have been made at the party’s
internal dispute resolution mechanism before moving
to the Political Party Disputes Tribunal (PPDT).
The PPDT disagreed with the respondents and
held that the respondents were merely seeking
to circumvent the litigation process, as the new
direct nomination of the first Respondent was made
pursuant to the decision of the NAT, which was
the party’s internal dispute resolution mechanism,
and from which no internal appeal was possible.
Therefore, the PPDT found that it had jurisdiction.
Further, the PPDT held that although there was
provision for direct nomination of a candidate in
the party’s constitution, the correct procedure
had not been followed in this case, as the Central
Committee that issued the direct nomination was
not the one that is given such powers by the party’s
constitution. As such, fresh nominations needed
to be conducted. On the question of excluding or
disregarding the nomination of results of the seven
polling stations that were affected by irregularities,
the PPDT reiterated its earlier decision in William
Chepkut v Jubilee Party and Another49 that fresh
elections ought only to be called in respect of
polling stations that are marred with irregularities.
Consequently, the PPDT nullified the direct
nomination of the first respondent for want of legal
authority by the issuers of the direct nomination and
ordered the conduct of fresh nominations in the seven
polling stations where there had been irregularities.
This decision is critical in that it allowed for repeat
nomination in areas where the will of the electorate
had not been fully expressed owing to irregularities.
Instances of direct nomination by political parties,
while practical in a select few instances, can be
subject to abuse by powerful players in a political
party. This can impede free and fair elections and
party democracy. This is because direct nomination
49
50
51
52
53
74
privileges the nominee while disenfranchising
voters and other candidates who are denied a
chance to compete fairly on the strength of their
ideas. Notably, the Political Party Disputes Tribunal
in deciding on the issue of direct nomination
remarked that given that the Party had conducted a
nomination process through voting by members of
the party, there was a legitimate expectation on the
part of members that if the results were annulled,
they would be allowed to express their will through
a repeat of the nomination exercise.50 In addition,
restricting the fresh election to only those polling
stations affected by irregularities would be fair to
all candidates and minimise on costs and time. The
PPDT’s decision was subsequently affirmed by the
High Court on a further appeal, which also stated
that it would be unreasonable to subject voters
in the various polling stations where there were
no irregularities to a fresh nomination exercise.51
The High Court in this case clarified that while
sitting on appeal against decisions of the PPDT, its
jurisdiction and powers were limited. This is unlike
when sitting as an election court under Section
80 of the Elections Act, where it exercises the full
powers of the High Court conferred on it by Article
165 of the Constitution. By this it has wider powers,
including summoning and compelling attendance of
witnesses as well as examining them.
Contrastingly, in Samuel Owino Wakiaga v Cyprian
Awiti & another,52 the PPDT affirmed the decision of
the party (Orange Democratic Movement, the same
party as in the Caroli Omondi case). This was where
the party’s National Executive Committee had
issued a direct nomination to a nominee following
an earlier nullification of nomination results. Citing
compliance with the party’s constitution, the
PPDT held that it would not interfere with internal
mechanisms and operations of a party where they
are conducted pursuant to the party’s governing
rules and regulations, as had been done in this
case.53 This judgment was made despite objections
by the complainant in this case that it had spent
huge sums of money in campaigning but then
been denied a chance for fresh nominations. This
Complaint No. 45 of 2017.
Para 57.
Caroli Omondi v John Mbadi & another [2017] eKLR, Election Petition Appeal No. 3 of 2017 <http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/137598/> (accessed on 12 April 2020).
[2017] eKLR, Complaint No. 52 of 2017 http://www.kenyalaw.org/tribunals/PoliticalTribunal/Samuel_Owino_Wakiaga_v_Cyprian_Awiti_&_another_%5b2017%5d_eKLR.pdf
(accessed on12 April 2020).
Para 24.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents