THE JURISDICTION OF THE
POLITICAL PARTY DISPUTES TRIBUNAL
IN PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES
RESOLUTION OF OTHER PRE-ELECTION
DISPUTES SUCH AS PROCUREMENT
OF ELECTORAL MATERIAL
There have also been instances where courts have
held that issues relating to whether one is eligible
to be nominated by a political party cannot be
determined by the PPDT in exercise of its functions
under Section 40 of the Political Parties Act of
2011. This was the finding in Republic v Chairman,
Political Parties Disputes Tribunal & 2 others Ex
Parte Susan Kihika Wakarura.63 The High Court held
that the determination of eligibility, which required
constitutional interpretation in this case, was a
weighty issue and that the PPDT is only vested with
jurisdiction to determine disputes between political
parties and members. The court proceeded to state
that the PPDT has jurisdiction only over disputes
that are limited to a particular member and a
particular political party, as opposed to those where
the dispute potentially affects other persons who
are not parties to the dispute.64
Other pre-election disputes that have fallen for
determination in the courts (albeit not election
courts) have ranged from procuring of election
materials and technology for use during elections
to constitution of a technical committee to oversee
elections.66 For instance, in Republic v IEBC
& 3 Others ex parte Coalition for Reform and
Democracy,67 the main opposition party challenged
the IEBC’s decision to award the tender for supply
and delivery of ballot papers and election results
declaration forms to a Dubai-based company
known as Al Ghurair, without facilitating public
participation in tendering. The High Court nullified
the IEBC tender decision due to the lack of public
participation, holding that it was important for the
IEBC to consult all relevant stakeholders even
before procuring technology, so as to maintain a
perception of fairness and inspire confidence as a
neutral arbiter and umpire.
There have also been contests on the jurisdiction
of the Political Party Disputes Tribunal and the
IEBC to determine pre-election disputes. The
Court of Appeal in Joseph Ibrahim Musyoki v
Wiper Democratic Movement- Kenya & another65
appears to have put to this to rest when it held
that the Tribunal has power to determine disputes
arising from party primaries and other disputes
between members and political parties before the
nomination stage. On the other hand, the Appellate
Court held that the IEBC assumes jurisdiction
once nomination has occurred. To provide clarity
between the two processes, the court reverted to
a statute, the Political Parties Act, which defines a
party primary as the process by which a party elects
or selects a candidate for an election but excluding
a party list, while nomination is submission to
the IEBC of the name of a candidate in accordance
with the Constitution and statute.
63
64
65
66
67
68
However, the Court of Appeal overturned the
High Court decision three days later.68 The Court
of Appeal found that there are exceptions to
the general principle that public participation is
required in all procurements by a public entity, one
such exception being direct procurement as in this
case. The Court of Appeal also noted that the High
Court had been wrong to issue orders of certiorari
and mandamus in this case, given the constitutional
timelines within which the presidential and general
elections are to be held. The High Court’s orders
could have threatened the political rights of millions
of Kenyans, so the Court of Appeal overturned them.
These issues became particularly contested
before the 2017 General Elections, largely owing
to suspicions from the opposition that the party
in power was seeking to compromise the results.
The suspicion was that the ruling party was doing
Republic v Chairman, Political Parties Disputes Tribunal & 2 others Ex Parte Susan Kihika Wakarura [2017] eKLR.
As above Para 45.
Joseph Ibrahim Musyoki v Wiper Democratic Movement- Kenya & another [2017] eKLR. <http://kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/141677> (accessed on 12 April 2020).
See example Kenneth Otieno v A-G & IEBC Nairobi High Court Petition 127 of 2017.
Republic v IEBC & 3 Others ex parte Coalition for Reform and Democracy Nairobi High Court Miscellaneous Civil Application No. 637 of 2016.
Civil Appeal No 224 of 2017.
77
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents