Faced with this enigma in Benjamin Ogunyo
Andama v Benjamin Andola Andayi & Ors,21 the
Kenya Court of Appeal could not find the proper
place to locate election petitions in Kenyan Law.
The court could only hold thus:
In our view, as has been said time and again,
election petitions form their own category and
are neither controlled by the Civil Procedure
Act and Rules made thereunder, nor are they
controlled by the Criminal Procedure Rules. They
are neither criminal nor civil in nature. We may
say there is an element of Public Law in them but
even that is not all correct. They are a class of
their own.22
Zimbabwean courts restated that election petition
proceedings are sui generis.23 The courts have come
to this conclusion as they seek to explain and justify
their conduct in sometimes adhering to the overly
technical nature of election petition proceedings.
This requires the petitioner to strictly comply with
the form of a petition, its service, and entire course
of adjudicating the dispute. The sui generis principle
has also been the scapegoat for courts to adopt
a narrow interpretation of their jurisdiction and
powers to extend or expand timelines.24
THE SUI GENERIS PRINCIPLE
HAS ALSO BEEN THE
SCAPEGOAT FOR COURTS
TO ADOPT A NARROW
INTERPRETATION OF
THEIR JURISDICTION
AND POWERS TO EXTEND
OR EXPAND TIMELINES
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
88
However, as if answering the Kenyan Court of
Appeal in the Andama case that found election
petitions as “neither civil nor criminal: but in
a class of its own, the Zimbabwean Electoral
Court pronounced itself on this exact question
in Mumbamarwo v Kasukuwere (Mumbamarwo
case).25 In this case, the Court was adjudicating on a
petition alleging criminal conduct on the part of the
respondent. The Court held as follows:
Election petitions are essentially civil proceedings
brought by one party against the winning
candidate who is the Member of Parliament
for that constituency. They are not criminal
proceedings and any wording in the Act that seems
to suggest to the contrary only serves to cause
confusion and blurs the legal position… A court
trying an election petition where the respondent
is accused of committing corrupt or illegal practice
sits as a civil court. In the absence of the Attorney
General or his duly authorised representative, the
court cannot in my view pronounce on the guilt
or otherwise of the respondent.26
The Court went on to question the intention of
the lawmaker for using language that implied
criminal proceedings proper as creating “… a grey
area for the court trying an election petition.”27 It
declined an interpretation of the law that would
lead to the conclusion that a court sitting to
determine an election petition involving criminal
conduct is called on to pronounce the guilt or
otherwise of the respondent. It insisted that election
petition proceedings are civil and never criminal,
notwithstanding the issue the court is called upon
to determine (criminal allegations). Demonstrating
its commitment to this conclusion, the Court
repeatedly invited the legislature “… to review
the entire [Electoral] Act and see if it adequately
prevents the mischief that it is set out to.”28
Benjamin Ogunyo Andama v Benjamin Andola Andayi & 2 Others Civil Application No. 24 of 2013, High Court Election Petition No. 8 of 2013, [2013] eKLR.
At page 6 of Benjamin Ogunyo Andama v Benjamin Andola Andayi & 2 Others Civil Application No. 24 of 2013, High Court Election Petition No. 8 of 2013, [2013] eKLR.
Chamisa v Mnangagwa (CCZ 42/18) [2018] ZWCC 42 (24 August 2018), p2.
Gore v Chimanikire HH 47/2008, where the Electoral Court stated that, ‘This court sitting as an electoral Court has no powers to condone any breach of the requirements as to
time frames or as to manner of service that are stipulated in the Act’.
Mumbamarwo v Kasukuwere HH 8/2002.
As above 6.
As above.
The Electoral At has since been periodically amended with the latest amendment in May 2018. However, the amendments did not address the issues vexing the court at the time
of the judgment.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents