[2019] CCJ 14 (AJ)
[8]
It is important, however, that the Court makes this point. In mandating that the
Government shall remain in office notwithstanding its defeat and the resignation
of the President and the Cabinet, Article 106 envisages that the tenure in office of
the Cabinet, including the President, after the Government’s defeat, is on a different
footing from that which existed prior to the vote of no confidence. Chancellor
Cummings-Edwards, citing Hogg1, the Canadian constitutional expert, was right to
note that:
“…The government continues in office as a caretaker government or an
interim government until the next elections ensue and a President is
appointed (or reappointed) depending on the results of that election.”
By convention, the government is expected to behave during this interim period as
a caretaker and so restrain the exercise of its legal authority. It is this caretaker or
interim role that explains the three month deadline, in the first instance, that the
Article lays down, in principle, for the holding of the fresh elections.
[9]
In all the circumstances, the Court makes the following declarations and orders:
a) The provisions of Article 106(6) and (7) of the Constitution apply to a No
Confidence motion;
b) Thirty-three votes constitute a majority of the 65 member National
Assembly;
c) Mr Charrandas Persaud was ineligible to be elected to the Assembly by
virtue of his citizenship of Canada but his vote on the motion of no
confidence was valid;
d) Nothing in the anti-defection regime established at Article 156(3) of the
Constitution rendered Mr Persaud incapable of casting his vote on that
motion in the manner in which he did;
e) The National Assembly properly passed a motion of no confidence in the
Government on 21 December 2018;
f)
Upon the passage of this motion of no confidence in the Government, the
clear provisions of Article 106 immediately became engaged;
1
Peter Hogg, Constitutional Law of Canada, 5th Edn Supplemented at 9(4)a
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents