Previous 42 / 123 Next

8/7/2020 SM-JIN-0035-2015 389-C1 391-B1 1er. Escrutador: JOSE VERA ROBLEDO 2do. Escrutador: JOSE JUAN ABUNDIZ GOMEZ 1er. Suplente: ANA ROCIO CASILLAS MONTAÑEZ 2do. Suplente: HUMBERTO JAVIER ARIAS MONTAÑEZ 3er. Suplente: REYES CASILLAS CRUZ Presidente: JUANA MARIA DE LOURDES GUILLEN MACIAS Secretario: JOSE TOMAS CORTES MEJIA 1er. Escrutador: RAFAEL BALDERAS QUIJANO 2do. Escrutador: DIEGO CALDERA MONTOYA 1er. Suplente: MANUEL CHAVEZ FLORES 2do. Suplente: RAQUEL ACOSTA MARTINEZ 3er. Suplente: ALFREDO ACOSTA MARTINEZ Presidente: BRAYAN MARTIN BALANDRAN CASTAÑEDA Secretario: HUGO KEVIN PADILLA SEGOVIA 1er. Escrutador: DORA ISABEL ZAMORA GARCIA 2do. Escrutador: JUAN ACOSTA GONZALEZ 1er. Suplente: MARINA GUADALUPE 2do. Suplente: BALANDRAN DE LUNA 3er. Suplente: JOSE VERA ROBLEDO JOSE JUAN ABUNDIZ GOMEZ JUANA MARIA DE LOURDES GUILLEN MACIAS JOSE TOMAS CORTES MEJIA RAFAEL BALDERAS QUIJANO DIEGO CALDERA MONTOYA BRAYAN MARTIN BALANDRAN CASTAÑEDA HUGO KEVIN PADILLA SEGOVIA DORA ISABEL ZAMORA GARCIA MARINA GUADALUPE BALANDRAN DE LUNA MARIA HORTENCIA CAMPOS SEGOVIA J GUADALUPE SEGOVIA ESPARZA 421-B1 443-B1 444-B1 Presidente: GRISELDA VERA REYES GRISELDA VERA REYES Secretario: REYNA JAZMIN ARAGON MEZA REYNA JAZMIN ARAGON MEZA 1er. Escrutador: EVELIN BELMAREZ HERNANDEZ KARLA ALEJANDRA GALLEGOS LUCIO 2do. Escrutador: JOSE ANTONIO PUGA RAMIREZ 1er. Suplente: MAYRA ELIZABETH ARAGON CHAVEZ 2do. Suplente: MARIBEL CASILLAS BERNAL 3er. Suplente: JUAN MANUEL FLORES CLETO Presidente: ELVIA DANILA FLORES RAMOS ELVIA DANILA FLORES RAMOS Secretario: JUAN FRANCISCO FLORES HERRERA JUAN FRANCISCO FLORES HERRERA 1er. Escrutador: ALFREDO ALVAREZ CAMACHO ALFREDO ALVAREZ CAMACHO 2do. Escrutador: BRENDA ALEJANDRA OCON PALACIO 1er. Suplente: JOSE ANTONIO VALENCIA ESPINDOLA 2do. Suplente: RICARDO MARCELO VELAZQUEZ SAUCEDO 3er. Suplente: ALMA ROSA DE SANTIAGO GARCIA Presidente: MARIA GUTIERREZ CASILLAS MARIA GUTIERREZ CASILLAS Secretario: JOSE DE JESUS CASTILLO SOLEDAD JOSE DE JESUS CASTILLO SOLEDAD 1er. Escrutador: GABRIELA DE LAZARO GASCA GABRIELA DE LAZARO GASCA 2do. Escrutador: MARIA INES AVILA GARCIA 1er. Suplente: MARCELA DEL ROSARIO MARMOLEJO GUTIERREZ 2do. Suplente: 3er. Suplente: 473-C4 MARIBEL CASILLAS BERNAL BRENDA ALEJANDRA OCON PALACIO MARÍA INEZ AVILA GARCIA ROBERTO DE LA ROSA LOPEZ OSCAR LOPEZ SAMBRANO Presidente: NORMA ANGELICA NIETO GUEL NORMA ANGELICA NIETO GUEL Secretario: ANABEL VALADEZ MACIAS ANABEL VALADEZ MACIAS 1er. Escrutador: LUIS ANTONIO ALFARO HERNANDEZ LUIS ANTONIO ALFARO HERNANDEZ 2do. Escrutador: JOSE LUIS AVIÑA CHAVEZ 1er. Suplente: LILIANA CASTOR MONTOYA 2do. Suplente: MARIA DE JESUS ZAMORA MORALES 3er. Suplente: GLORIA ACOSTA GUTIERREZ https://www.te.gob.mx/colecciones/sentencias/html/SM/2015/JIN/SM-JIN-00035-2015.htm LILIANA CASTOR MONTOYA 42/123

Select target paragraph3

● ● ●

PAN v. PRI (SM JIN 0035 2015)

Judgment

Question Presented: Whether the Governor's presence and irregularities are sufficient to annul the election results.

Alleged Acts: The Governor of Aguascalientes posted photos on his personal Twitter account which was transitioned to the official webpage of the government. These photos included him traveling to polling stations with candidates. Further, the plaintiff alleges that the elections should be annulled because of errors and inconsistencies in the minutes, voter were not received by authorized individuals, the polling station did not open and close at the allotted times, and that violence and pressure was forced upon voters at the ballot boxes. Lastly, the plaintiff indicates that the campaign financing was constructed in a way where the expenditures exceeded the maximum amount.

Summary: The court determined that the ballot box originating in Aguascalientes, ballot box 450 C1, was null for violating Article 75, paragraph 1, subsection (e) of the Media Law. The court determined that violation involving the elections must be substantial and of sufficient gravity that it would prevent certainty and validity as to which candidate would be ranked first. The court determined that the candidate did not exceed the campaign spending cap and that unreported expenses were not sufficient to exceed that cap. However, the court determined that because people, other than those authorized, received the ballots, the votes from that polling place were invalid. This, in combination with the governor’s presence in the district as evidenced by his Twitter account, suggests a violation of impartiality.

Conclusion: The court annulled the election results from one polling station stating that the Governor violated the impartiality and equality of elections because his involvement in the election became public knowledge.

Legal Issue(s)

Disputing Results
Electoral Administration Irregularities
Electoral Integrity
Social Media

Region: Americas

Country: Mexico

Language of Decision

Spanish

Court: Electoral Court

Election Type: General

Date of decision: Aug 4, 2017

Geolocation

Latitude: 19.43318644

Longitude: -99.13401778

: Geolocation

Primary Documents

SM-JIN-0035-2015.pdf
Spanish
Download View

Election Judgments - IFES

Select target paragraph3

PAN v. PRI (SM JIN 0035 2015)

Primary Documents

Notifications