CAAMAÑO VALLE v. SPAIN JUDGMENT
Section 2 – Right to vote
“1. All Spanish citizens of legal age not falling within any of the categories listed in
the following section have the right to vote.”
Section 3 – Disenfranchisement
“1. The following have no right to vote:
...
b) Persons declared incapacitated by a final judicial decision, provided that that
decision specifically declares the person in question incapable of exercising suffrage.
c) Persons residing in a mental hospital by order of a court, in the event that the
court explicitly declares in its order that the person in question is incapable of
exercising the right to vote.
2. For the purposes of this section, courts or tribunals having jurisdiction to declare a
person’s legal incapacity or to order a person’s residence in a mental hospital must
specifically decide whether that person is incapable of exercising the right to vote, and
if that is the case, they shall require that fact to be noted in the Civil Register.”
19. Institutional Law 2/2018 of 5 December 2018 modified the LOREG
so that it guaranteed the right to vote to persons with a disability,
eliminating the provisions of the LOREG relating to the possibility of
depriving disabled people of the right to vote. Institutional Law 2/2018,
which entered into force on 7 December 2018, amended the wording of
section 3 of the LOREG, so that it now reads, where relevant, as follows:
“(i). Sub-paragraphs (b) and (c) of section 3 § 1 are deleted.
(ii). The second paragraph of section 3 shall read as follows:
Everyone shall be entitled to exercise his right to vote, knowingly, freely and
voluntarily, whatever the manner in which that vote is cast and whatever means of
support he may require.
An eighth, additional, provision is added with the following wording:
As of the entry into force of Organic Law 5/1985 of 19 June modifying the Organic
Law on the General Electoral System in order to adapt it to reflect the International
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, any limitations on the exercise
of the right to vote established by judicial resolution (on the basis of section 3(1)(b)
and (c) of Organic Law 5/1985 – no longer in force) shall cease to have effect. Those
persons whose right to vote has been limited or annulled owing to disability shall fully
regain that right by virtue of the law”.
20. The relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure read as
follows:
Article 759
“1. In incapacity proceedings, in addition to examining evidence adduced in
accordance with the provisions of Article 752, the court shall hear the next-of-kin of
the allegedly incapacitated person, examine the person himself and agree on which
expert opinions in respect of the claims made in the application for a declaration of
7