2019 Presidential Election: Post-Election Report
According to the preliminary statement of the International Election Observation Mission (IEOM)1,
some interlocutors alleged so-called ‘technical’ candidates who are in fact affiliated with the leading
candidates had registered in part to obtain seats in lower-level commissions, which undermined the
principle of equal representation as well as the purpose of the proportional allocation of executive
positions. Some nominees for election commissions were not aware they had been proposed to be a
member of the election commission. While no such issues were reported in the second round, the
role of “technical candidates” in proposing nominees to lower level election commissions should be
significantly restricted.
The Presidential Election Law fails to set a deadline for replacements of commissioners at lower-level
election commissions; presidential candidates are free to replace election commissioners appointed
by them at any time, including before, during and after election day. According to the IEOM, 39
percent of the initially appointed members of DECs established for the April 21 first round were
replaced by the presidential candidates who nominated them or on their own initiative before election
day. The lack of any restriction on the right to replace members of election commissions has been
repeatedly criticized by the OSCE/ODIHR, the Venice Commission, and IFES as it has a negative impact
on the professionalism of the election commissions. After the initial formation of DECs for the second
round, candidates submitted requests for changing 8 percent of the initially appointed members.
These replacements were criticized by domestic and international observers, including for rendering
training provided to DEC members less effective.
According to the Civil Network OPORA, 65
percent of the DEC members initially
appointed before the first round previously
served on an election commission. This figure
is somewhat lower compared to the 2010
presidential election (78 percent of the
commissioners had previous election
experience) and the 2014 presidential
election (72 percent had previous
experience). The share of DEC members
appointed for the second round with
IFES in cooperation with the CEC and the joint IFES-CEC Training
previous election experience increased to 69
Center organized a five-day training of trainers (TOT), who in turn
percent, indicating that 31 percent of the conducted 106 regional trainings for more than 3,000 District
second round DEC commissioners were not Election Commission (DEC) members.
commission members during the first round.
The CEC, with IFES’ technical assistance and through the CEC Training Center, organized a wide-scale
training of DEC and PEC members before the first round to ensure that they could effectively exercise
their duties and were aware of key election procedures. However, the fact that presidential candidates
can appoint untrained commissioners to serve on election commissions in both the first and second
round, their frequent and unrestricted replacement of commissioners, and the narrow timeframes for
establishing the DECs and PECs for the second round vote still poses a significant risk and may have a
negative impact on the professionalism and performance of election commissioners in future
1
The International Election Observation Mission (IEOM) was a joint effort of the long-term OSCE/ODIHR Election Observation
Mission and short-term observer delegations from the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, the Parliamentary Assembly of the
Council of Europe, the European Parliament and the NATO Parliamentary Assembly.
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents