IFES Ukraine
Election observation
The Presidential Election Law provides that the election process can be observed by domestic
observers (from parties, candidates, and NGOs) and international observers representing foreign
states and international organizations. To become accredited to observe the election, an NGO must
have election observation-related provisions in its charter. Members of the NGO are registered by the
DECs, while international observers are registered by the CEC. Domestic observers are granted broad
rights, including filing complaints and lawsuits against decisions, actions or inactions of the election
commissions, taking photos and video records, as well as the right to be present at the meetings of
the election commissions without prior invitation or consent.
For the presidential election, the CEC
accredited 139 NGOs, of which 132 had the
right to observe the election nationwide.
Only 82 of the 139 accredited NGOs
registered observers for the first and second
round. This is the highest number of NGOs
accredited to observe in the country’s
history. Many NGOs, according to OPORA,
were directly or indirectly affiliated with
specific parties and candidates, thus
undermining the independent nature of
Observers monitor the voting process at a polling station in Kyiv,
election observation and discrediting the
Ukraine.
overall idea of observation. Some NGOs
accredited by the CEC were connected to paramilitary groups. A large number of observers can have
a negative impact on DEC and PEC operations, especially if they appear in huge numbers in the
premises of the election commissions or interfere in election day processes. While these fears did not
manifest themselves in this election, measures are needed to decrease the number of frivolous and
party/candidate affiliated domestic observers registered as NGOs. To decrease the number of NGOs
eligible to observe the election, the Presidential Election Law could impose additional requirements
for NGOs, such as registration at least one year before election.
The CEC announced that 2,700 international observers from 41 states and international organizations
were registered to observe the second round (compared to 2,300 observers from 36 states and
organizations in the first round). International observers from the Russian Federation were banned
from observing the election, in violation of the 1990 OSCE Copenhagen Document. It is questionable
to bar citizens of a certain state from observing elections as members of multilateral election
observation efforts from an international organization of which Ukraine is member, since these
citizens do not represent their country but the sending organization. The criteria for rejecting
international observers should be specified in election laws and should comply with international
standards and best practices.
DECs are in charge of registering domestic observers. Given that DECs are formed in the middle of the
election process, domestic observers are de facto deprived the right to observe key election-related
procedures such as candidate nomination and registration, early stages of the election campaign and
the very formation of the DECs. The procedure for accreditation and registration of domestic
24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents