IFES Ukraine Executive summary The presidential election in Ukraine held across two rounds on March 31st and April 21st represents an important electoral milestone for democracy in Ukraine. This was the first major national election held since the Central Election Commission (CEC) was renewed in September 2018. Observers from a diverse range of international and domestic monitoring missions stated that election day was carried out in a generally professional and smooth manner across the country. The efforts of all levels of election administration – as well as the large margin of victory for Volodymyr Zelenskyi – leave little doubt that this election represents a democratic achievement for all involved. However, there are a number of outstanding issues that must be addressed both to improve future presidential elections as well as to prepare Ukraine for the anticipated parliamentary elections in only a few months. It is critical that election stakeholders reflect seriously on the 2019 presidential election to draw lessons learned and consider observer recommendations. The legal framework requires significant change to meet international standards and best practices. While the Presidential Election Law is arguably the least flawed of the laws governing elections, only a few of the recommendations for improvement by the Council of Europe’s Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) and domestic observer missions have been addressed. The laws governing elections must be adapted and clarified in order to remove conflicting language, clarify key definitions and roles of electoral stakeholders, require sanctions for electoral offenses, and further bolster the democratic process to make it more inclusive and transparent. In addition to legal shortcomings, a number of outstanding issues pertaining to the administration of the presidential election surfaced in domestic and international observer reports as well. Key areas of concern includes: the centralized nature and perceived lack of transparency of the CEC; the large composition of lower-level election commissions and the frequent replacement of their members, undermining their efficiency and professionalism; the lack of effective, proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for election-related offences; the cumbersome procedures for changing the place of voting without changing a voter’s address and de-facto introduction of active voter registration for certain groups of citizens; a general lack of accessibility for persons with disability at odds with Ukraine’s international commitments; short timelines for election dispute resolution; the lack of campaign finance transparency; negative campaigning; abuse of administrative resources and the lack of a level playing field in the coverage of the campaign in media; as well as the significant number of “technical” candidates standing for election. Despite these issues and challenges, there were a number of significant improvements noted by observers and electoral stakeholders alike for this election. The major improvements noted by the observers include: better preparedness of the CEC and other authorities to combat cyber-attacks on key election infrastructure; a competitive campaign environment with respect for the fundamentals freedoms; lack of major violations during voting, vote counting and vote tabulation; the effective role of police in maintaining and protecting public order on election day; and high-quality wide-scale training of the election commissioners provided with IFES technical assistance. This report provides analysis of key electoral issues as well as achievements from the 2019 presidential election, and offers recommendations for stakeholders to improve future democratic processes. 4

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents