INCAL JUDGMENT OF 9 JUNE 1998
7
19. In a judgment of 6 July 1993 the Court of Cassation upheld all the
operative provisions of the impugned judgment, after observing that, regard
being had to the nature and length of the sentence imposed at first instance,
it was not necessary to hold a hearing.
20. On 23 August 1993 the prosecuting authorities decided, at the
applicant’s request, to stay execution of the prison sentence for four months.
II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE
A. Criminal law
1. The Criminal Code
21. The relevant provisions of the Criminal Code read as follows:
Article 311 § 2
“Public incitement to commit an offence
Where the incitement [to commit an offence] is done by means of mass
communication, of whatever type, by tape recordings, gramophone records,
newspapers, press publications or other published material, by the circulation or
distribution of printed papers or by the placing of placards or posters in public places,
the terms of imprisonment to which convicted persons are liable shall be doubled…”
Article 312
“Non-public incitement to commit an offence
Whosoever expressly praises or condones an act punishable by law as an offence or
incites the population to break the law shall be sentenced to between six months’ and
two years’ imprisonment and a … fine of between six thousand and thirty thousand
liras.
Whosoever expressly arouses hatred and hostility in society on the basis of a
distinction between social classes, races or religions, or one based on allegiance to a
particular denomination or region, shall be sentenced to between one and three years’
imprisonment and a fine of between nine thousand and thirty-six thousand liras. If this
incitement is done in a manner likely to endanger public safety, the sentence shall be
increased [by one third to one half].
The penalties to be imposed on those who have committed the above-mentioned
offences by the means listed in Article 311 § 2 shall be doubled.”
22. A conviction under Article 312 § 2 entails further consequences,
particularly with regard to the exercise of certain activities governed by
special legislation. For example, persons convicted of an offence under that
section may not found associations (Law no. 2908, section 4(2)(b)) or trade