Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
75
http://www.judis.nic.in
that certain candidates were indulging in bribery of
voters and the fact that a huge amount of about Rs. 2
crores were seized by enforcement agencies on the day
of poll which was suspected to be used for bribery in that
electipn. The said rescission was challenged before the
Hon’ble High Court of Jharkhand in Jay Shankar Pathak
and Pradeep Kumar Balmuchu v Election Commission o
f India
[ATR 2012 (JHAR) 58] wherein the Petitioners challenged
not only the jurisdiction of the Election Commission of
India but also the reasonability of its decision. The
Hon’ble High Court not only upheld the decision of the
Election Commission but also hailed it as a necessary step
to ensure free and fair elections. It is noteworthy to
mention the following observations of the Hon’ble High
Court:
“17. [...] we are o f the considered opinion that
the present issue raised by the writ petitioners certainly
question the power o f Election Commission in taking a
step to rescind the election, even in gravest to gravest
his rarest to rarest case as it is the only step of such
great consequence taken by the Election Commission
after independence of country and in our opinion, the
decision is fully supported by reason and based upon
cogent trustworthy evidence, though limited to purpose,
so as to not to give chance to any person to enjoy high
status of being Member o f Parliament, It is true some
innocent and honest candidate may have to suffer as all
are not corrupt but such honest person should sacrifice
his opportunity in larger public interest.
19. [...] Therefore, in the present case, the
Election Commission was right in its
wisdom to take immediate action and recommend
cancellation of election notification itself that fresh
election may be conducted expeditiously.
25. [...] Assuming that none of the party was
involved in illegal consideration for vote of its member
then also in the fact situation where the involvement of
the money was so much and out of which some of the
money has been intercepted by the vigilant cell of the
Income Tax Department on the instruction of the Election
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents