Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
88
http://www.judis.nic.in
(3) Assuming a constitutionally vested capacity under
Article 324 to direct re-poll, is it exercisable only in
conformity with natural justice and geared to the sole goal
of a free, popular verdict if frustrated on the first occasion?
Or, is the Election Commission immune to the observance
of the doctrine of natural justice on account of any
recognised exceptions to the application of the said
principle and unaccountable for his action even before the
Election Court?”
36. Having held against the maintainability of the
writ petition, we should have parted with the case finally.
But counsel for both the candidates and, more particularly,
the learned Addl. Solicitor-General, appearing for the
Election Commission, submitted that the breadth,
amplitude and implications, the direction and depth of
Article 324 and, equally important, the question of natural
justice raised under Article 324 are of such public
importance and largely fallow field, going by prior
pronouncements, and so strategic for our democracy and its
power process that this Court must decide the issue here
and now. Article 141 empowers and obligates this Court to
declare the law for the country when the occasion asks for
it. Counsel, otherwise opposing one another, insistently
concurred in their request that, for the working of the
electoral machinery and understanding of the powers and
duties vested in the functionaries constituting the
infrastructure it is essential to sketch the ambit and import
of Article 324. This point undoubtedly arises before us even
in considering the prohibition under Article 329 and has
been argued fully. In any view, the Election Tribunal will be
faced with this issue and the law must be laid down so that
there may be no future error while disposing of the election
petition or when the Commission is called upon to act on
later occasion. This is the particular reason for our
proceeding to decide what the content and parameters of
Article 324 are, contextually limited to situations analogous
to the present.
38. Article 324, which we have set out earlier, is a
plenary provision vesting the whole responsibility for
national and State elections and, therefore, the necessary
powers to discharge that function. It is true that Article 324
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents