Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
91
http://www.judis.nic.in
unto itself. Broad authority does not bar scrutiny into
specific validity of the particular order.
41. Our conclusion on this limb of the contention is
that Article 324 is wide enough to supplement the powers
under the Act, as here, but subject to the several
conditions on its exercise we have set out.
52. So now we are face to face with the naked issue
of natural justice and its pro tem exclusion on grounds of
necessity and non-stultification of the on-going election.
The Commission claims that a direction for re-poll is an
“emergency” exception. The rules of natural justice are
rooted in all legal systems, not any “new theology” and are
manifested in the twin principles of nemo judex in causa
sua and audi alteram partem. We are not concerned here
with the former since no case of bias has been urged. The
grievance ventilated is that of being condemned unheard.
Sporadic applications or catalogue of instances cannot
make for a scientific statement of the law and so we have
to weave consistent criteria of application and principles
for carving out exceptions. If the rule is sound and not
negatived by statute, we should not devalue it nor hesitate
to hold every functionary who affects others' right to it.
The audi alteram partem rule has a few facets two of which
are (a) notice of the case to be met; and (b) opportunity to
explain. Let us study how far the situation on hand can
coexist with canons of natural justice. While natural justice
is universally respected, the standards vary with situations
contracting into a brief, even post-decisional opportunity,
or expanding into trial-type trappings.
53.Ridge v. Baldwin [(1964) AC 40 : (1963) 2 All ER
66] is a leading case which restored light to an area
“benighted by the narrow conceptualism of the previous
decade”, to borrow Professor Clark's expression. [ Natural
Justice : Substance and Shadow ‘Public Law’ Journal —
Spring 1975] Good administration demands fairplay in
action and this simple desideratum is the fount of natural
justice. We have already said that the classification of
functions as “judicial” or “administrative” is a stultifying
shibboleth, discarded in India as in England. Today, in our
jurisprudence, the advances made by natural justice far
exceed old frontiers and if judicial creativity belights
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents