Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
92
http://www.judis.nic.in
penumbral areas it is only for improving the quality of
government by injecting fairplay into its wheels.
54. The learned Addl. Solicitor-General welcomed the
dramatic pace of enlargement in the application of natural
justice. But he argued for inhibiting its spread into
forbidden spaces lest the basic values of Article 329 be
nullified. In short, his point is that where utmost
promptitude is needed — and that is the raison d'etre of
exclusion of intermediate legal proceedings in election
matters — natural justice may be impractical and may
paralyze, thus balking the object of expeditious
completion. He drew further inspiration from another
factor to validate the exclusion of natural justice from the
Commission's actions, except where specifically stipulated
by statute. He pointed out what we have earlier mentioned
— that an election litigation is one in which the whole
constituency of several lakhs of people is involved and, if
the Election Commission were under an obligation to hear
affected parties it may, logically, have to give notice to
lakhs of people and not merely to candidates. This will
make an ass of the law and, therefore, that is not the law.
This reductio ad absurdum also has to be examined.
55. Law cannot be divorced from life and so it is that
the life of the law is not logic but experience. If, by the
experiential test, importing the right to be heard will
paralyze the process, law will exclude it. It has been said
that no army can be commanded by a debating society, but
it is also true that the House of Commons did debate,
during the days of debacle and disaster, agony and crisis of
the Second World War, the life-and-death aspects of the
supreme command by the then British Prime Minister “to
the distress of all our friends and to the delight of all our
foes” — too historic to be lost on jurisprudence. Law lives
not in a world of abstractions but in a cosmos of
concreteness and to give up something good must be
limited to extreme cases. If to condemn unheard is wrong,
it is wrong except where it is overborne by dire social
necessity. Such is the sensible perspective we should adopt
if ad hoc or haphazard solutions should be eschewed.
92. Diffusion, even more elaborate discussion, tends
to blur the precision of the conclusion in a judgment and so
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents