Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
87
http://www.judis.nic.in
creating officers, powers and duties, delegation of
functions and location of polling stations. The precise
exercises following upon the calendar for the poll
commencing from presentation of nomination papers,
polling drill and felling of votes, culminating in the
declaration and report of results are covered by specific
prescriptions in the Act and the Rules. The secrecy of the
ballot, the authenticity of the voting paper and its later
identifiability with reference to particular polling stations,
have been thoughtfully provided for. Myriad other matters
necessary for smooth elections have been taken care of by
several provisions of the Act.
17. We now enter the constitutional zone relating to
the controversy in this case. Although both sides have
formulated the plural problems with some divergence, we
may compress them into three cardinal questions:
“(1) Is Article 329(d) a blanket ban on all manner of
questions which may have impact on the ultimate result of
the election, arising between two temporal termini viz. the
notification by the President calling for the election and
the declaration of the result by the returning officer? Is
Article 226 also covered by this embargo and, if so, is
Section 100 broad enough to accommodate every kind of
objection, constitutional, legal or factual, which may have
the result of invalidation of an election and the declaration
of the petitioner as the returned candidate and direct the
organisation of any steps necessary to give full relief?
(2) Can the Election Commission, clothed with the
comprehensive functions under Article 324 of the
Constitution, cancel the whole poll of a constituency after
it has been held, but before the formal declaration of the
result has been made, and direct a fresh poll without
reference to the guidelines under Sections 58 and 64(A) of
the Act, or other legal prescription or legislative backing? If
such plenary power exists, is it exercisable on the basis of
his inscrutable “subjective satisfaction” or only on a
reviewable objective assessment reached on the basis of
circumstances vitiating a free and fair election and
warranting the stoppage of declaration of the result and
directions of a fresh poll not merely of particular polling
stations but of the total constituency?
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents