Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
89
http://www.judis.nic.in
has to be read in the light of the constitutional scheme and
the 1950 Act and the 1951 Act. Sri Rao is right to the extent
he insists that if competent legislation is enacted as
visualised in Article 327 the Commission cannot shake itself
free from the enacted prescriptions. After all, as Mathew,
J. has observed in Indira Gandhi (p. 523) (see p. 136, paras
335-6):
“In the opinion of some of the Judges constituting the
majority in Bharati's case [Kesavananda Bharati v. State of
Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225.] rule of law is a basic structure of
the Constitution apart from democracy.
The rule of law postulates the pervasiveness of the
spirit of law throughout the whole range of Government in
the sense of excluding arbitrary official action in any
sphere.”
And the supremacy of valid law over the Commission argues
itself. No one is an imperium in imperio in our
constitutional order. It is reasonable to hold that the
Commissioner cannot defy the law armed by Article 324.
Likewise, his functions are subject to the norms of fairness
and he cannot act arbitrarily. Unchecked power is alien to
our system.
39.Even so, situations may arise which enacted law
has not provided for. Legislators are not prophets but
pragmatists. So it is that the Constitution has made
comprehensive provision in Article 324 to take care of
surprise situations. That power itself has to be exercised,
not mindlessly nor mala fide, not arbitrarily nor with
partiality but in keeping with the guidelines of the rule of
law and not stultifying the Presidential notification nor
existing legislation. More is not necessary to specify; less is
insufficient to leave unsaid. Article 324, in our view,
operates in areas left unoccupied by legislation and the
words “superintendence, direction and control, as well as
‘conduct of all elections’, are the broadest terms”. Myriad
maybes, too mystic to be precisely presaged, may call for
prompt action to reach the goal of free and fair election. It
has been argued that this will create a constitutional
despot beyond the pale of accountability; a Frankenstein's
monster who may manipulate the system into elected
despotism — instances of such phenomena are the tears of
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents