Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
90
http://www.judis.nic.in
history. To that the retort may be that the judicial branch,
at the appropriate stage, with the potency of its benignant
power and within the leading strings of legal guidelines, can
call the bluff, quash the action and bring order into the
process. Whether we make a triumph or travesty of
democracy depends on the man as much as on the Great
National Parchment. Secondly, when a high functionary
like. the Commissioner is vested with wide powers the law
expects him to act fairly and legally. Article 324 is geared
to the accomplishment of free and fair elections
expeditiously. Moreover, as held in Virendra [Virendra v.
State of Punjab, AIR 1957 SC 896 : 1958 SCR 308] and
Harishankar [Harishankar Baglav. State of M.P., AIR 1954 SC
465 : 1954 Cri LJ 1322 : (1955) 1 SCR 380] discretion vested
in a high functionary may be reasonably trusted to be used
properly, not perversely. If it is misused, certainly the
Court has power to strike down the act. This is well
established and does not need further case law
confirmation. Moreover, it is useful to remember the
warning of Chandrachud, J.:
“But the electorate lives in the hope that a sacred
power will not so flagrantly be abused-and the moving
finger of history warns of the consequences that inevitably
flow when absolute power has corrupted absolutely. The
fear of perversion is no test of power. [Indira Nehru Gandhi
v. Raj Narain, 1975 Supp SCC 1, 251 (para 661) : (1976) 2
SCR 347, 657] ”
40. The learned Addl. Solicitor-General brought to
our notice rulings of this Court and of the High Courts which
have held that Article 324 was a plenary power which
enabled the Commission to act even in the absence of
specific legislation though not contrary to valid legislation.
Ordering a re-poll for a whole constituency under
compulsion of circumstances may be directed for the
conduct of elections and can be saved by Article 324 —
provided it is bona fide necessary for the vindication of the
free verdict of the electorate and the abandonment of the
previous poll was because it failed to achieve that goal.
While we repel Sri Rao's broadside attack on Article 324 as
confined to what the Act has conferred, we concede that
even Article 324 does not exalt the Commission into a law
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents