Bar & Bench (www.barandbench.com)
10
are made against a particular candidate, the nature of
remedial proceedings envisaged are judicial, whereby the
issue must be heard in accordance with Section 80 and the
other concomitant provisions of the RP Act, as per which
the issue is to be determined by a competent court. Even in
cases where the Election Commission seeks to disqualify a
candidate,
the
consequences,
same
wherein
is
an
the
action
carrying
proceedings
civil
cannot
be
conducted in violation of the principles of natural justice.
The impugned notification seeks to bye-pass the judicial
process envisaged under law for determination of the
existence of such corrupt practices by ostensibly penalizing
the same through an administrative order.
(xi) In any event, the circumvention of the said
judicial process by the 1st Respondent or the Hon'ble
President of India is an action that is envisaged neither
under
the
Constitution
nor
under
any
statute.
A
determination has been made regarding the culpability of a
certain
candidate
in
the
EC
Recommendations.
Furthermore, based on this ex parte determination of guilt
on the part of one candidate, punishment has been
recommended for all parties involved by countermanding
the entire election rather than punishing the concerned
candidate. As such, the Impugned Notification suffers from
a fundamental misapplication of law and is ex facie liable
to be set aside.
http://www.judis.nic.in