22
MAGYAR KÉTFARKÚ KUTYA PÁRT v. HUNGARY JUDGMENT
Commission (SEC), the legal predecessor to the National Election
Commission, stated as follows:
“...
Section 70(1) of the Electoral Procedure Act [Act C of 1997] provides that ‘[t]he
voter shall put the ballot paper into an envelope and place it in the ballot box in front
of the polling station committee’.
It follows from the grammatical and logical interpretation of this provision and from
the principles governing the election procedure laid down in section 3(a) and (d) of
the Electoral Procedure Act, namely the protection of the fairness of elections and the
prevention of election fraud, as well as from the principles of good faith and the
exercise of rights in accordance with their purpose, that the ballot paper is an
authentic document the purpose of which is to reflect the electoral intentions of voters
and to establish the election result.
Consequently, it infringes the principle of exercise of rights in good faith and in
accordance with their purpose if a voter treats the ballot paper as his or her own and
removes it from the polling station. Removal of the ballot paper from the polling
station may also be conducive to election fraud, the prevention of which furthers the
interest of the public in maintaining the fairness of elections.
The use of the ballot paper in a manner contrary to the purpose for which it was
originally intended may also violate the constitutional requirement of the
confidentiality of elections.
According to the SEC’s position, the physical ballot paper does not constitute the
property of the voter. In other words, the principle laid down in section 3(b) of the
Electoral Procedure Act (voluntary participation in the vote) does not authorise a voter
to remove the ballot paper from the polling station.”
E. Guidelines of the National Election Commission no. 12/2014
38. Guidelines no. 12/2014 of the National Election Commission (NEC)
on the removal of ballot papers from the polling station and the taking of
photographs of ballot papers provide, in so far as relevant, as follows:
“1. Section 182(1) of the Electoral Procedure Act provides that the voter must place
the ballot paper in an envelope and drop it in the ballot box. As is clear from the
grammatical and legal interpretation of this provision – taking into account also the
protection of fair elections and the bona fide exercise of voting rights in accordance
with their purpose – ballot papers are official documents whose purpose is to
represent the choice of voters and to establish the results of voting.
2. Thus, if a voter treats a ballot paper as his or her own and takes it out of the
polling station or takes a photograph of it before placing it in the envelope or dropping
it in the ballot box, he or she infringes the principle of the bona fide exercise of voting
rights in accordance with their purpose. Taking ballot papers out of the polling station,
or taking photographs, videos, and so forth of them, can also result in electoral fraud,
the prevention of which [furthers] the public interest in protecting the fairness of
elections.
3. The use of ballot papers [in a manner] contrary to their purpose may also infringe
the principle of secrecy of elections as enshrined in Hungary’s Fundamental Law. The
secrecy of elections also encompasses the secrecy of ballot papers; thus, taking