of the polls breached Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules, the elections were
conducted substantially in compliance with electoral law. Accordingly, I would
dismiss the grounds of appeal in the respondents’ counter-notices which sought to
challenge this decision. In any event, the election in each contested constituency
was not conducted in a manner that was not substantially in compliance with
election law so as to render the election invalid, regardless of whether the results
were affected or not. Accordingly, I would dismiss the grounds in the respondents’
counter-notices which sought to challenge this decision.
[227]
The learned judge erred when she invalidated the election of the appellants, Mrs.
Quinn-Leandro, Mr. Maginley and Mr. Spencer on the ground that she could not
say that the results in the contested constituencies were not affected by the late
opening of the polling stations and the consequent late start in voting in the St.
George, the St. John’s Rural North and St. John’s Rural West constituencies.
Accordingly, I would allow the grounds of the appellants’ appeal which challenge
the trial judge’s decision on this issue.
[228]
The judge’s order that the parties shall bear their own costs in the High Court is
hereby affirmed. The parties shall also bear their own costs in the appeal
proceedings.
Order
[229]
In the foregoing premises, the order that I would make on this appeal is as follows:
(1) The appeal by the appellant, Mrs. Quinn-Leandro, against the judge’s
decision, contained in her judgment dated 31st March 2010, which declared
that Ms. Quinn-Leandro was not validly returned as the elected Member of the
Legislature of Antigua and Barbuda for the St. George constituency, after
elections which were conducted on 12th March 2009, is allowed; and that
101
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents