evidence emerged which disclosed that the presiding officer voted for a number of
persons whom he said were nervous. It was argued on behalf of the petitioner
that since nervousness was not a form of physical incapacity within the Election
Rules, what the presiding officer did amounted to an irregularity which could
invalidate the election. Counsel for the respondent countered that since this issue
was not pleaded, the court would, in effect, be permitting the petitioner to rely on
new facts which were not pleaded, although the time for amending the petition had
long passed. Redhead J agreed with the latter contention.
He ruled that the
petitioner could not rely on the new evidence adduced at the trial.37 His approach
was correct and informs the approach which this court would take.
In the
premises, I would allow this ground of the appeals by Mrs. Quinn-Leandro and Mr.
Spencer.
[61]
Notwithstanding this conclusion, however, I shall, based upon Mr. Guthrie’s
suggestion, consider the merits of the issue of late voting as it arose in these
cases. This is not however intended to signal a change in the principles of the law
as to pleadings in election cases within the jurisdiction of this court.
Late voting
[62]
The evidence at the trial clearly discloses that there was voting after 6.00pm at
various polling stations in the St. George and St. John’s Rural West
constituencies. The question of late voting by persons who joined the lines after
6.00pm was raised in relation to the St. John’s Rural West constituency. The
learned trial judge found, as a matter of fact, that there was late voting in the 2
constituencies but only by persons who had entered the lines by 6:00pm. The trial
judge found, as a matter of fact, that late voting by persons who joined the lines
after 6:00pm was not borne out by the credible evidence. Respondents Jonas and
Simon challenge this finding of fact in their counter-notices.
37
See O.E.C.S. Law Reports, Volume 1, at page 249.
29
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents