petitioner Simon in the witness statements filed by Jurmin Smith, Ynes James and
Julian Wallace. In his witness statement41, Jurmin Smith said that he joined the
line at Green Bay at 5:30pm but at 6:00pm the gate was closed and he and 100
other persons were locked out and so prevented from voting, while others in the
line inside the gate were permitted to vote after 6:00pm.
In her witness
statement42, Ynes James said that she arrived at Green Bay at 3:30pm, but after
6:00pm she was told that she was in the wrong line. However, by the time she got
to the correct line it was already closed and she was not allowed to vote. In his
witness statement43, Julian Wallace said that he reached the polling station at
5:20pm but discovered that he should have been at another polling station. By the
time he got there it was after 6.00pm and he was not allowed to vote. They all
complained that they were not allowed to vote after 6:00pm, but petitioner Simon
did not call these witnesses.
[71]
Finally, Mr. Martineau sought to raise acquiescence in answer to the late voting
claim.
He submitted that there was evidence of acquiescence because of
evidence that Ms. Christian took her supporters to the polls to vote while watching
supporters of Mr. Spencer voting late.
While I shall consider the other
submissions by counsel for the parties in the following paragraphs, I would at this
juncture dismiss the submissions on acquiescence, which does not arise in this
case. As Mr. Astaphan pointed out, Ms. Christian is not in a position to acquiesce
in anything since she is not the petitioner.
Decision on late voting
[72]
The trial judge had the opportunity to see and hear the witnesses. She rejected
the evidence of Pena and Gomez. In challenging the judge’s findings, Mr. Guthrie
submitted that the judge should have found that the more likely story was that
given by Pena and Gomez that a considerable number must have entered the
CTB II pages 100-102.
Ibid pages 122-123.
43 Ibid. pages 132-133.
41
42
33
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents