construction interpretation. The duty of the Court is to seek to ascertain
the intention of the legislature while at the same time ensuring that the
meaning does not lead to any absurdity or repugnance. The Bruno’s
case is very persuasive and, in my view, aptly describes the legal
position.”
[81]
It is noteworthy that the judge did not accept the submissions by Mr. Mendes and
Mr. Martineau that the words in Rule 1(7) that “the polling shall take place between
the hours between 6:00am to 6:00pm” meant that voting could properly commence
at any time after 6:00am; at 10:00am or even 4:00pm, for example.49 According to
the judge, this would be an absurdity because it would be impossible ever to find
that there was a breach of Rule 1(7) for late opening as long as polling began after
6:00am but before 6:00pm. The judge expressed the view that this could never
have been the intention of the legislature. She held that Rule 1(7) means that
polling must commence at 6:00am because the legislature intended electors to
commence voting at that time.50 In my view, there is great logical force in that
reasoning. Counsel for the appellants think otherwise.
Submissions on behalf of the appellants
[82]
Mr. Mendes and Mr. Martineau insisted that the trial judge was wrong to hold that
the late opening of the polls breached Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules, first,
because the Rule does not state that polling must begin at 6.00am. Counsel
contended that, in its ordinary meaning, the Rule states that polling must take
place between 6:00am and 6:00pm. Counsel contended that this happened on
elections day because voting commenced in each constituency after 6.00am but
before 6:00pm.
[83]
Counsel for the appellants submitted, further, that Rule 1(7) should be contrasted
with section 1 of the United Kingdom Elections (Hours of Poll) Act, 1885.
49
50
At paragraph 221 of the judgment.
See paragraph 222 of the judgment.
37
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents